What would be the best contrast between the two different endings in "Great expectations"?
To determine the best contrast between the two different endings of "Great Expectations," we first need to understand the details of each ending. Charles Dickens initially wrote an ending which some critics argue is more pessimistic. However, Dickens later revised the ending to create a revised version that is generally considered more hopeful. To fully comprehend the contrast, it's essential to compare and analyze the two endings side by side:
Original (Alternative) Ending:
- In the original ending, the story concludes with Pip running into Estella, who has remarried, and they have a brief conversation.
- The overall tone of this ending is more somber and reflective, suggesting that some of the characters' hopes and dreams remain unfulfilled.
- Pip and Estella part ways without any explicit indication of a future relationship, leaving the reader with a sense of ambiguity.
Revised Ending (Published):
- In the revised ending, Pip encounters Estella again, and there is a stronger suggestion of a future relationship, albeit subtly, as they hold hands and walk away together.
- This ending is more optimistic and uplifting, offering the possibility of love and happiness for the characters.
- Pip reflects on the lessons he has learned, realizes the value of self-improvement, and finds peace within himself.
The key contrast between the two endings lies in their tones and implications. The original ending leaves some threads of the story unresolved, presenting a more uncertain and melancholic conclusion. In contrast, the revised ending provides a sense of closure and more hopeful prospects for the main characters.
It's important to note that interpretations of these endings may vary, and different readers may have differing opinions on which is the better contrast. To thoroughly understand and analyze the contrasts, it is recommended to read both endings and delve into the themes, character development, and messages conveyed within each one.