WHAT WAS FRANKLIN D. ROOSEVELT'S COURT PACKING SCHEME? WHAT IMPACT DID IT HAVE ON HIS PRESIDENCY AND WHY DID HE DO IT. PLEASE DISCUSS
Here are a number of sites:
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&ie=ISO-8859-1&q=+FRANKLIN+D.+ROOSEVELT%27S+COURT+PACKING+SCHEME%3F&btnG=Google+Search
Franklin D. Roosevelt's court packing scheme refers to his proposal in 1937 to add up to six additional justices to the U.S. Supreme Court. The purpose of this scheme was to change the ideological balance of the court, which at the time was blocking some of his New Deal policies. Here's a detailed discussion of the court packing scheme and its impact on FDR's presidency:
1. Background and Motivation:
- By 1937, some of Roosevelt's New Deal policies were being declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. This frustrated him because he believed the court was impeding his efforts to combat the Great Depression.
- Roosevelt's motivation for court packing was to reshape the judiciary and bring it more in line with his policies. He wanted to ensure that the court would interpret the Constitution in a way that would support his expansive view of federal power.
2. The Proposal:
- On February 5, 1937, Roosevelt introduced a bill to Congress that, if passed, would have allowed him to appoint up to six additional justices to the Supreme Court.
- Roosevelt argued that the court was overburdened and needed assistance, but it was widely seen as an attempt to "pack" the court with justices sympathetic to his policies.
3. Public Perception and Opposition:
- The court packing scheme faced significant opposition, not only from Republicans but also from many Democrats who believed Roosevelt was tampering with the independence of the judiciary.
- Critics accused Roosevelt of trying to undermine the checks and balances system and consolidate too much power in the executive branch.
4. Impact on Roosevelt's Presidency:
- Although the court packing scheme failed to materialize (the bill did not pass), it had a lasting impact on Roosevelt's presidency.
- The proposal strained his relationship with Congress and weakened his political standing. The failure was seen as a significant defeat and damaged Roosevelt's reputation.
- However, in the aftermath of the court fight, a shift in the court's composition occurred naturally, as some older justices retired or passed away. Subsequently, the court began upholding more New Deal legislation, thus alleviating some of Roosevelt's frustrations.
5. Broader Effects:
- The court packing scheme highlighted tensions within the government between the executive and judicial branches, as well as the importance of a balance of power.
- The episode initiated a public debate about the role of the Supreme Court and its potential vulnerability to political manipulation.
In summary, Franklin D. Roosevelt's court packing scheme was an attempt to reshape the Supreme Court's composition and align it with his New Deal policies. Although it failed, it had a lasting impact on his presidency, straining his relationship with Congress and damaging his reputation. Nonetheless, the episode led to a natural shift in the court's composition and a more favorable disposition towards New Deal policies.