Since you read an actual letter from Melville to Hawthorne, you got a glimpse of their friendship. Write an essay explaining why you agree or disagree with the following statement:
Melville feels a warm, affectionate bond with Hawthorne.
Use two examples from the letter to support your arguments. I need help with this question.
Which letter did you read?
Why do you think Melville feels affectionate toward Hawthorne?
LETTER TO NATHANIEL HAWTHORNE, JUNE [1?] 1851 that is the letter I read.
You can find several examples in the paragraph beginning:
"It seems an inconsistency to assert unconditional democracy in all things, . . .'
http://xroads.virginia.edu/~MA96/atkins/cmletter.html
To understand whether Melville feels a warm, affectionate bond with Hawthorne, we can examine the letter from Melville to Hawthorne. Analyzing the language, tone, and content of the letter will provide insights into the nature of their friendship. However, since I am an AI and cannot access specific letters without external resources, I can guide you on how to find the required information yourself.
First, locate the letter written by Melville to Hawthorne. This might require some research, as there are several letters exchanged between the two authors. Once you have found the relevant letter, read it carefully, paying close attention to the language used and the overall tone of the text.
Look for instances in the letter where Melville expresses sentiments of warmth and affection towards Hawthorne. These could be direct statements or subtle indications.
Here are two examples that might help you in making your argument:
1. Analyze the use of endearments: Melville may use terms of endearment to suggest a close bond with Hawthorne. Look for expressions such as "my dearest friend" or "beloved Hawthorne." These terms indicate a certain level of fondness and affection.
2. Observe the tone and emotional depth: Pay attention to the general tone of the letter. If Melville expresses emotions like gratitude, admiration, or longing, it suggests a deep bond and affection for Hawthorne. Look for phrases that convey these sentiments, such as "I cannot express how grateful I am for your friendship" or "Your presence in my life has made a significant impact...". These expressions indicate a profound connection and emotional attachment.
Utilizing these examples and arguments will enable you to evaluate whether Melville indeed feels a warm, affectionate bond with Hawthorne as stated in the statement. Remember to provide specific quotes or references from the letter to back up your analysis.
By following these steps, you can gather the necessary information to agree or disagree with the statement while providing supporting evidence from the letter itself.