# Algebra

posted by .

I am trying to find the domain for x(x+2)(x+2)/(x-2)(x+2). I canceled the (x+2)'s. The only problem is that my book says the domain cannot equal -2. But I say it cannot equal 2 either (along with -2). (-2-2)(-2+2) is equal to (2-2)(2+2), right? Or what did I do wrong? Thanks!

• Algebra -

(-2-2)=0 (-2+2)= -4
(2-2)=0 (2+2)= 4 so they are not the same because the first one is a negative 4 and the second is a positive 4

• Algebra -

x(x+2)(x+2)/(x-2)(x+2) line 1
= x(x+2)/(x-2) line 2

you are dealing with explicit vs implicit restrictions.
Some authors of textbooks will list as restrictions all values which make any of the denominators zero.
Other authors, and yours is one of them, will restrict only those factors which were divided out

let me explain:
let x=2
line 1 = 32/0 which is undefined
line 2 = 8/0 which is undefined
so technically line 1 is still equal to line 2 when x=2 and no need to restrict it as (x cannot be equal to 2)

let x=-2
line 1 = 0/0 which is indeterminate (wait till you take Calculus for that one)
line 2 = 0/-4 = 0 a real number
so clearly line 1 is no longer equal to line 2, making x = -2 a "necessary" restriction.

It is a fine distinction. I used to accept both types of answers.

## Similar Questions

1. ### i lied. very quick calc problem.

f(x) = abs(sin(x)), -pi less than or equal to x less than or equal to pi g(x) = x^2 let H(x) = g(f(x)) i got that H(x) would equal sin^2(x). THIS IS WHERE I AM STUCK! find the domain of H. do i still need to account for "-pi less than …
2. ### math

Identify the domain and range of the following: f(x) = 4-x^2, -5<x<-1 3/2x + 3/2, -1<x<3 (both "<" signs are actually less than or equal to) x+3, 3<x<10 (x<10 is actually less than or equal to) All three are …
3. ### Algebra 2

Okay so I need help with basically how to find the domain, range, and how to solve if it says Find the value of f(3). Let the f function be defined by f(x) = the square root of x + 1 for -1 is less than or equal to x less than or equal …
4. ### Algebra

Hello again, I am now working on trying to find the relation of x = 1 - y^2, along with the domain and range. Then written in interval notation. I think I am ok with figuring out the domain and range on a graph but my problem is how …
5. ### Algebra

Hectorâ€™s service club is raising money by wrapping presents in the mall. The function f(x) = 3x describes the amount of money, in dollars, the club will earn for wrapping x presents. They only have enough wrapping paper to wrap 1000 …
6. ### Algebra

Hectorâ€™s service club is raising money by wrapping presents in the mall. The function f(x) = 3x describes the amount of money, in dollars, the club will earn for wrapping x presents. They only have enough wrapping paper to wrap 1000 …
7. ### Algebra 2

Hi, I need help finding the domain and range of the Quadratic Model on part b. I've included part a. just in case you may need it. a.The parabolic path of a thrown ball can be modeled by the table. the top of the wall is at (5,6). …
8. ### SAVE ME ( MATH)

function p(t) has a domain of 1 less than or equal to t less than or equal to 12 range of -40 < p less than or equal to 160 Find the domain and range for. Enter the exact answers A) P(1/4t+4) B) -1/10p(2t)+46
9. ### Pre calc quick question

if a problem says f(x)=square root x^2-16; x less than or equal to -4. Find domain and range. to do this i set up the equation like x^2-16 less than or equal to -4. However by doing this I am runnning into complications findng domain …
10. ### math

So for this question it says, the graph of the function f(x)= radical of x+4 is shown. The domain of the function is 1) {x|x is greater than 0} 2) {x|x is greater or equal to 0} 3) {x|x is greater than -4} 4) {x|x is greater than or …

More Similar Questions