Communication Theory
posted by Audrey
Professor Nostradamus conducted an empirical or observed communications study in his laboratory where he convincingly found a connection between two variables.
The link concluded that Variable “X” always increased when the subject was exposed to Variable “Y”. By repeating the study over the course of several years he found the same results in his laboratory each time. What can he not say?

GuruBlue
What do YOU think he can not conclude based on logic? We will be happy to comment after we read your answer.

Audrey
I would say that Professor Nostradamus would not be able to say that his model or theoretical simplified version representation of the real world is an explanatory device, although it can be used to play an important suggestive role in the formulation of his theory. Any thoughts?

GuruBlue
You did not address the question...The questions does not say anything about a simplified version representation of the real world.
The question is saying  after years of testing in his laboratory, he has found a consistent connection between two variables... What can he NOT SAY... what is missing in his study? 
Audrey
Can he not say that there isn't a connection between the two variables?

GuruBlue
NO...he can't... the studies "in his laboratory" have shown a consistent contection.

GuruBlue
What would have to be done to prove that the connection is consistent everywhere.

Audrey
Further testing. But if he did the same test over and over, he concluded that others would get the same result. So could it be that others results might vary?

GuruBlue
Yes, further testing...but there is one thing that can be done that would prove that the testing in "his lab" was valid....

Audrey
The same tests under different conditions? Or using different subjects? I am lost on this one

GuruBlue
RIGHT!!!! the tests have been consistent at HIS lab...to prove that his tests are valid , they would have to be done somewhere else by unbiased testers.... Then he could say that his tests were probably valid.

Audrey
So he could not say his tests were vaild unless others could verify the results?

GuruBlue
Absolutely!!!

GuruBlue
If something is to be true, it has to be TRUE everywhere.

Audrey
Thanks for all your help!

GuruBlue
welcome entirely <G>
Respond to this Question
Similar Questions

math
8 divided by 3 plus 6= You asked 8 divided by 3 plus 6= (8/3) + 6 = 2(2/3) + 6 or 8/3 + 18/3 = ? 
science
what should you ask yourself when looking for an independent variable in an experiment? 
Communication Studies
Professor Nostradamus conducted an empirical or observed communications study in his laboratory where he convincingly found a connection between two variables. The link concluded that Variable “X” always increased when the subject … 
Pyschology
can anyone help me with this. I can't think of anything or explain to me. Post an example of a simple experiment of your own creation by following this format: I would like to investigate the effects of _____________ on this behavior: … 
Stats
In each of the four examples listed below, one of the given variables is independent (x) and one of the given variables is dependent (y). Indicate in each case which variable is independent and which variable is dependent. I. Rainfall; … 
Probability
For each of the following statements, determine whether it is true (meaning, always true) or false (meaning, not always true). Here, we assume all random variables are discrete, and that all expectations are welldefined and finite. … 
statistics
In a correlation study, we seek to determine; *if the IV cause an outcome in the DV. *Which variable is the cause and which variable is the effect. *The direction of causation. *How well one variable predicts another variable. 
Science
There can be several controlled variables. If an experiment is to be useful, only one variable at a time can be manipulated intentionally. All other variables must be controlled throughout all parts of the experiment. If more than … 
Social Research Methods
Professor Phil wishes to study the marital expectations of men and women. State the independent variable. State the dependent variable. Write a statement of the problem. Write an hypothesis. How would you operationalize the variables? 
algebra
in a relationship between variables, what is the variable called that changes in response to another variable?