In the story of" Milkweed by Jerry spenilli"
There is a question I did not understand
Question is.
How does Misha's observation reveal his state of mind? Why didn't he simply say,"the knots in the barbed wire were shiny"?
Can anyone help me answer this question please?
Don't you think he was contrasting the horrors of the Holocaust and the ghetto with the luxury of ladies' earrings?
umm NOPE
How does Misha's observation reveal his state of mind? Why didn't he simply say, "the knots in the barbed wire were shiny"?
Misha reveals his state of mind because of Misha... complete the rest you should know-how.
In order to answer this question, we need to analyze Misha's observation and how it reveals his state of mind in the story "Milkweed" by Jerry Spinelli.
Misha's observation refers to the knots in the barbed wire, which were described as "shiny." Instead of simply stating that, the question asks why Misha didn't just say, "the knots in the barbed wire were shiny."
To understand the reasoning behind Misha's observation and why he didn't provide a straightforward description, we need to consider the broader context of the story. "Milkweed" is set during World War II, specifically in the Warsaw Ghetto, where Jews were confined in a densely populated and oppressive living condition by the Nazis.
Misha, the protagonist, is a young boy who is homeless and orphaned. He survives by scavenging for food and other items. Throughout the story, Misha's observations are often reflective of his state of mind, his survival instincts, and the environment in which he lives.
Misha's description of the knots in the barbed wire as "shiny" instead of directly stating their appearance highlights his imaginative and optimistic mindset. It suggests that Misha is trying to find beauty, hope, and wonder even in the midst of a harsh and brutal reality.
By using the word "shiny," Misha highlights the contrast between the drabness and despair of the ghetto and the glimpses of something brighter that he notices. It reflects his ability to find solace or a momentary escape from his harsh surroundings by focusing on small details that bring him some sense of joy or curiosity.
Therefore, Misha's observation reveals his state of mind as being resourceful, imaginative, and resilient. He chooses to see the knots in the barbed wire as "shiny" instead of stating it directly to emphasize his determination to find hope and beauty in an otherwise bleak setting.
In conclusion, Misha's observation in "Milkweed" reveals his state of mind by highlighting his resourcefulness and resilience. He chooses to describe the knots in the barbed wire as "shiny" to emphasize his imaginative and optimistic outlook in a challenging and oppressive environment.