Marvin is planning to open a fabric dyeing business. He plans to do large scale dyeing of both fabric bolts and ready-to-wear garments. The source of business will be garment makers and cleaners. He has worked in this part of the fashion industry and knows how much capital he will need to buy the equipment required for this specialized activity.
He has some cash, and he is trying to decide whether to incorporate or to form a partnership. What would you say to him about the major advantages and disadvantages of chartering a corporation rather than forming a partnership?
First of all, if he is looking to have limited liability, then he should go with a corporation. A partnership has direct exposure and tax consequences. The company pays their tax and the the shareholder pays again with their personal returns via K-1. An LLP (limited liability partnership) would be an option if he was just contributing capital.
As for the corporation side, unless there are reasons for the corporation, I would suggest an S- Corp. You can elect to change this to a C- Corp later if you choose. There are some differences in treatment from the IRS. The tax liability/responsibility is passed to the shareholders through K-1's.
Neka kiser, vice president of operation mountain national bank, has instructed the bank’s computer programmer to use a 356-day year to compute interest on depository account payable . neka also instructed the programmer to use a 360-day year to compute interest on loans receivable.
When deciding between incorporating or forming a partnership for his fabric dyeing business, Marvin should consider the major advantages and disadvantages of each option. Here's an explanation of the key points to consider:
Advantages of incorporating a corporation:
1. Limited liability: One of the main advantages of incorporating a corporation is that it provides limited liability protection. This means that the shareholders' personal assets are generally protected from the company's debts and liabilities. If there are legal issues or financial losses, the shareholders' personal assets are not at risk (unless they have provided personal guarantees).
2. Separate legal entity: A corporation is considered a separate legal entity from its owners (shareholders). It can sue or be sued, own property, enter into contracts, and carry on business activities in its own name.
3. Easier access to capital: In general, it can be easier for a corporation to raise capital compared to a partnership. It has the ability to issue new shares, attract investors, apply for loans, or even go public by selling shares on the stock market. This can give Marvin more options to finance the purchase of equipment and future growth.
4. Continuity and transferability: A corporation can continue its existence even if the original shareholders or directors leave or pass away. Ownership can be easily transferred through the sale of shares, allowing for long-term succession planning.
Disadvantages of incorporating a corporation:
1. Complexity and costs: Setting up a corporation and complying with legal requirements can be more complex and costly compared to forming a partnership. Corporations must adhere to various regulations, file annual reports, pay incorporation fees, hold shareholder meetings, etc.
2. Double taxation: One of the potential drawbacks of incorporating a corporation is the issue of double taxation. The corporation itself is subject to corporate income tax, and when profits are distributed to shareholders as dividends, those dividends are also subject to personal income tax. This can result in higher overall tax liabilities.
3. Increased regulations and oversight: Corporations are subject to more regulatory oversight and scrutiny than partnerships. They may need to comply with additional reporting, disclosure, and governance requirements.
Advantages of forming a partnership:
1. Simplicity and flexibility: Forming a partnership is generally simpler and more flexible than incorporating. There are fewer formal legal requirements and regulations to meet, making it easier and less expensive to set up.
2. Pass-through taxation: Unlike a corporation, a partnership does not face double taxation. The partnership itself is not taxed on its profits. Instead, income and losses are "passed through" to the partners, who report them on their individual tax returns.
3. Shared management and decision-making: In a partnership, decision-making can be shared among the partners, which can promote collaboration and a diversity of ideas.
Disadvantages of forming a partnership:
1. Unlimited liability: One of the main disadvantages of a partnership is that the partners have unlimited personal liability for the debts and obligations of the business. If the partnership faces financial issues or legal liabilities, the partners' personal assets can be at risk.
2. Limited access to capital: Partnerships often have more limited options for raising capital compared to corporations. Partners may need to rely mostly on their own resources or loans since partnerships cannot sell shares.
3. Potential conflicts: In a partnership, disputes or conflicts can arise among the partners regarding the management, decision-making, or profit-sharing. Without proper legal agreements in place, these disagreements can create strain and potentially lead to the dissolution of the partnership.
Ultimately, Marvin should carefully consider these advantages and disadvantages in the context of his specific needs, goals, and preferences. He may want to consult with legal and financial advisors to make an informed decision that aligns with his business objectives.