Carlos is playing in the sandbox. Thomas approches the sandbox, observes Carlos for a moment, then knocks over the bucket Carlos has just filled with sand. Carlos pushes Thomas away saying, Get out of here. Thomas begins to cry.
How would an authoritian caregiver most likely solve the problem between Carlos and Thomas?
A. Help Carlos to refill his bucket.
B. Ask Carlos if Thomas can play too.
C. Ignore the situation and let the boys resolve it.
D. Tell Thomas he was bad to knock over the bucket and will have to leave the sandbox.
My answer is D. Can you tell me if I am right.
Right.
Thanks
To determine if your answer is correct, let's analyze the options and consider the approach of an authoritarian caregiver in this situation:
A. Help Carlos to refill his bucket: This option focuses on addressing Carlos's immediate need of refilling the bucket. While it might provide a solution to Carlos's problem, it does not address the conflict between Carlos and Thomas.
B. Ask Carlos if Thomas can play too: This option involves considering both Carlos and Thomas's needs. By engaging Carlos in the decision-making process, it aims to promote empathy and cooperation. However, this approach may not align with an authoritarian caregiver's style, as it includes granting Carlos the authority to make the decision.
C. Ignore the situation and let the boys resolve it: This option suggests allowing the boys to resolve the conflict on their own. It implies a hands-off approach, which an authoritarian caregiver might not prefer, as they typically expect to maintain control over situations.
D. Tell Thomas he was bad to knock over the bucket and will have to leave the sandbox: This option aligns more closely with an authoritarian caregiver's behavior. It involves assigning blame to Thomas and issuing a punishment by asking him to leave the sandbox.
Considering the characteristics of an authoritarian caregiver, it is likely that option D would be their preferred approach. Therefore, your answer, D, is correct for an authoritarian caregiver.