Middle school Engllish
posted by Jin .
My son recently had an English test where he was marked incorrectly, but I think he was correct. I just need some verification. The question:
"The whole neighborhood watched him climb in his old pickup and ______ down our street at full speed."
The word to use was the form of "careen" His answer was "careen" but his teacher corrected him and said it should be in the past tense "careened." Who is correct? Thanks for your help
I vote for "careen" because it's parallel with "climb." The whole neighborhood is not the subject.
The present tense "careen" is correct; otherwise the sentence would be saying that the "neighborhood watched ... and careened ... " which clearly doesn't make sense.
The word "careen" needs to be parallel to "climb" (present) not "watched" (past).
careen is correct. The neighborhood was watching what was happening in the present.
Thank you for your help! I asked my son to go back to school and let his teacher know that my husband and I agreed with him. He told me his teacher would not listen. Hopefully she will listen to your responses and believe him.
You're very welcome.
I suggest that your son politely explain our rationale in supporting "careen." Also note, that the three of us are all retired teachers -- middle school, high school, and college.