Sentencing

posted by .

Do you agree or disagree with the argument that crime seriousness and prior criminal records are not legally relevant variables?

Many agree, many disagree, I would like to hear more opinions and why?

I agree. Prior crime does not equate to current crime.

If that were so, we could also say that no past record of crime means you never will commit a crime.

Once a good guy, always a good guy. Once a bad guy, always a bad guy. [Both statements are ridiculous.]

  • Sentencing -

    However, if a person has a prior criminal record, it is more likely she will commit another crime. When person with no record commits crime, it makes sense to give him the benefit of the doubt and give him a light sentence.

  • Sentencing -

    The seriousness of the crime is a factor — that's what distinguishes between most misdemeanors and felonies.

    You are phrasing previous record in an all-or-nothing manner. In contrast, it is more a matter of probabilities. Past behavior is a relatively good indicator — all other things being equal — of what to expect in future behavior. However, in real life, "all other things" are not equal. This is a fact that makes prediction difficult.

    There is also the intent of the perpetrator. Did s/he intend harm?

    I hope this helps a little more. Thanks for asking.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. math

    statement: Middle-school stundents do not know enough about pet nutrition. students were asked to rate the statement on a 1 to 5, where 1=stongly disagree 2= disagree 3=neither agree nor disagree 4=agree 5= stongly agree. what van …
  2. Agree or disagree with this statement US history

    Agree or disagree and why?-- just taking a poll Article One in the US constitution leaves little room for interpretation of the powers of Congress.
  3. English 7: Wk Sht - Perseverance

    I have to answer these 4 questions and in those question they ask me and I have to say if I agree or disagree. I just need help on like what do they mean. 1. You need a positive attitude tp persevere in difficult situations?
  4. English

    I am writing an essay about James Baldwin's Go Tell It on the Mountain, but the essay prompt asks me to disagree or agree with the interpretation of an critical essay we read about this book. For my essay, do I state whether I agree …
  5. Statistics

    I need assistance in calculating the mean and standard deviation from data collected using 2 surveys, strongly agree, agree, neutral, disagree, strongly disagree. Can someone help please?
  6. English

    In English conversations, people often say that they agree or disagree with each other. There are many ways of agreeing or disagreeing and the "one" you use depends on how strongly you agree or disagree. --------------------- What …
  7. English

    1. I totally disagree with you. 2. I completely disagree with you. 3. I entirely disagree with you. ( Do they mean that I don't agree with you at all?
  8. English

    Posted by rfvv on Wednesday, February 1, 2017 at 7:59pm. 1. I totally disagree with you. 2. I completely disagree with you. 3. I entirely disagree with you. ( Do they mean that I don't agree with you at all?
  9. English

    Thank you for your help. One more similar question goes as follows. I have summarized a little. 1. I disagree with you a hundred percent. 1-1. I don't agree with you at all. (Are both the same?
  10. English

    One possible theme of call of the wild could be that only the strongest survive. Explain how this relates to darwins theory of natural selection and the survival of the fittest. Do you agree or disagree with this idea?

More Similar Questions