Comprehensive Argument Analysis. Must choose two topics. When finished one should have tow sources per topic. Sources can come from Magazines, Academic Journals, News and Web sites. Then must analyze four sources. Provide the title of the souce, provide the source citation, identify the principal issue presented, indetify the principal issue, bias presented by the author, explain how you determined this? Identify areas that are vague or amiguous. Identify and name any fallacies used by the author. Identify the aurhor's argument valid or invalid, sound our unsound, strong or weak. Does the author use moral reasoning how to determine this or why not.
Doris, this is homework you have to do on your own. When you come up with some ideas, then someone will help you elaborate. I can help you with the next question, but please make an effort with this one.
I am stuck on this question. Would like to do my article on homeless and homeless people. Then I must answer 10 questions about the articles.
To complete a comprehensive argument analysis with two topics and four sources, you will need to follow the steps below:
Step 1: Choose Two Topics
Select two topics that you would like to analyze. These topics should have varying viewpoints or controversies to allow for a comprehensive analysis.
Step 2: Find Sources
Gather two sources for each topic from a variety of reliable sources such as magazines, academic journals, news articles, or reputable websites. Ensure that the sources have different perspectives on each topic.
Step 3: Analyze the Sources
For each source, you will need to analyze the following elements:
a) Title of the Source
Provide the title of the selected source.
b) Source Citation
Include the full citation of the source, including the author(s), publication date, title of the article or study, and the publication or website it was sourced from.
c) Principal Issue Presented
Identify the main issue or argument presented by the author in the source.
d) Principal Issue Bias
Determine if the author exhibits any bias towards a particular viewpoint. Look for language, tone, or any evidence of a predisposition that might influence their perspective.
e) Vague or Ambiguous Areas
Identify any parts of the source that are unclear, vague, or ambiguous. This could include contradictory information, lack of evidence, or confusing statements.
f) Fallacies Used
Identify any logical fallacies used within the source. These may include ad hominem attacks, straw man arguments, circular reasoning, or hasty generalizations.
g) Validity, Soundness, Strength, or Weakness
Evaluate the author's argument by determining its validity (whether it logically follows), soundness (whether the argument is both valid and has true premises), and the strength or weakness of the supporting evidence.
h) Moral Reasoning
Assess if the author employs moral reasoning in their argument. Look for appeals to ethics, values, or principles. Consider whether moral reasoning strengthens or weakens the overall argument.
By following these steps, you will be able to complete a comprehensive argument analysis for each of your chosen topics. Remember to use critical thinking and evidence-based reasoning to provide a thorough and unbiased analysis.