What strategies do you use for revising a paper?
How do you know when to accept feedback from another source?
What makes feedback valuable to you?
I let a paper sit for a few hours or overnight before revising. Then I go over it carefully, making sure the words say exactly what I want to say.
I accept feedback from another source if I feel that source is an expert or the feedback makes sense to me.
See above.
Now -- what are YOUR answers to the above questions???
Once excellent method of revising is after letting it sit a bit, read it out loud from back to front. If it does not flow properly, if there are leaps in logic, if there are grammatical errors, you will quickly see them. Look especially at your conclusion; then read the topic sentences of each of the paragraphs; then read the thesis statement. Do they all relate as they should?
Here are a couple of excellent websites with checklists that can help you revise and edit successfully:
http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/composition/proofing.htm
http://www.sheboyganfalls.k12.wi.us/staff/dehogue/FSSH/proof.htm
=)
To revise a paper effectively, you can use various strategies that involve both self-reflection and external feedback. Here are a few strategies to consider:
1. Take a break: Step away from your paper for a while to gain fresh perspective. This will help you approach the revision process with a clear mind.
2. Read for understanding: Read through your paper carefully to ensure that your ideas are clear and that your arguments flow logically. Make note of any sentences or paragraphs that seem confusing or disconnected.
3. Focus on structure and organization: Check if your paper follows a logical structure. Ensure that each paragraph supports the main point and that there is a clear progression of ideas. You can use headings and subheadings to guide readers through your paper.
4. Check grammar and style: Pay attention to grammar, spelling, punctuation, and sentence structure. Look for any unclear or awkward phrasing. Consider using grammar and spellcheck tools, but also manually review your writing.
5. Seek feedback from others: Share your paper with trusted colleagues, classmates, or professors and ask for their input. Different perspectives can provide valuable insights and identify areas of improvement.
Now, let's move on to the second question concerning accepting feedback from another source. Here are a few considerations:
1. Expertise and credibility: Consider the expertise and credibility of the person providing the feedback. If they have relevant knowledge or experience in the subject matter, their feedback is likely to be valuable.
2. Context and purpose: Understand the context in which the feedback is given. If the person has a good understanding of the assignment's requirements or the goals of your writing, their feedback can be more meaningful.
3. Consistency with other feedback: If multiple sources provide similar feedback, it is a good sign that there might be an issue that needs addressing. Consistent feedback from different sources can help you identify recurring problems or areas of improvement.
4. Objectivity and clarity: Look for feedback that provides specific suggestions or examples rather than vague or subjective comments. Clear, objective feedback can help you make concrete revisions.
Lastly, let's discuss why feedback is valuable. Here are a few reasons:
1. Identifying blind spots: Feedback often highlights areas that you may not have noticed or overlooked. It can reveal weaknesses or errors that you were unaware of, helping you to improve your writing.
2. Different perspectives: Feedback allows you to view your work from various angles. Others may bring unique insights, ideas, or alternative interpretations that enrich your writing.
3. Audience perception: Feedback helps you understand how your work is perceived by others. It allows you to gauge if your intended message is effectively communicated and adjust accordingly.
4. Growth and improvement: Valuable feedback promotes personal growth as a writer. By implementing suggestions and addressing weaknesses, you develop stronger writing skills over time.
Remember, the value of feedback lies in your willingness to listen, critically evaluate, and use it constructively to enhance your work.