Essay suggestions

posted by .

I'm doing an essay on the book The Children of Izieu. My thesis is - The lives of 44 children were unreasonably exterminated in the Holocaust.

The book is about Children who are captured by Klaus Barbie from the House of Izieu and taken to a death camp in Auschwitz.

Two of my arguments are - they were young and harmless so they shouldn't have been exterminated. And that they were exterminated in a barbaric manner. Can anyone help me come up with more arguments? Thanks!

  • Essay suggestions -

    If you are arguing the children were "unreasonably exterminated", does that mean they could have been reasonably exterminated?
    Your arguement-they were young and harmless- if thy were old and harmless should they have been exterminated? Or old and harmful? Secondly, if there is such a thing as exterminated in a barbaric manner, is there the contra of exterminated in a civilized (humane) manner?
    My point is this: Be careful of your wording, and avoid such logical pitfalls.
    I think a better thesis is focused on the loss of the innocent: It includes Modern Africa, Iraq, Pakistan, and wherever terror or inhumanity reigns. Why does God allow it? Why do we allow it?
    Good luck

  • Essay suggestions -

    I agree with Bobpursley.

    I've been thinking about your essay for a while -- and have a hard time accepting your mealy-mouthed thesis. The children were murdered -- not by just one crazed individual -- but by a so-called civilized nation.

    Since the focus of your essay is on this book, I suggest you rewrite your thesis to make it stronger. Then concentrate on the individual children whose lives were cut pathetically short by the barbarians.

  • Essay suggestions -

    Thank you both for your suggestions! The book, in a way, is like a memorial. Should I change my thesis to something related to the importance of remembering the holocaust?

  • Essay suggestions -

    Yes. I think you should. That would be a good idea.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. French

    I have to write a thesis for the book Les Enfants d'Izieu and I am struggling to come up with something. Can anyone give me suggestions or ideas?
  2. English for previous french question

    It won't work for some reason. Hopefully it will work this time. In 1939, a global military conflict named World War 2 started. It divided many of the world nations into two military alliances: the Allies and the Axis Powers. World …
  3. English: Children's Literature

    I have to write an 8 page essay about Picture Books in Children's Literature. My thesis is: "Children can learn reading and writing from picture books, because it helps the child develop cognitive skills." Can you give me your input …
  4. English 9

    Hey, I made a thesis for my essay, but is it any good?
  5. english

    A good strong thesis statement about the children's book Corduroy by Don Freeman
  6. English College composition I

    I need help on writing a thesis statement about child abuse/my story. so far this is what i have THESIS #1 "While other children were beaten to death or were abused in so many ways. I was one of the few who survived child abuse and …
  7. english 11

    Question about Nora's children in the book the A Doll's house.?
  8. English

    1. Each student has his / her own book. (How do you read "/"?

    The ratio of boys to girls at a day care cent is 5 to 4. Which of the following cannot be the total number of children at the center?
  10. literature for kids

    Which is NOT a benefit of sharing books to young children?

More Similar Questions