Chem?

posted by .

Which of these elements can't have an expanded octet in a Lewis structure?
P,O,Br,N,S,C,B,Si

I think its O,C,B,N. Are elements that don't have a d oribial arent supposed to be included?

  • Chem? -

    We usually count those element that don't have d orbitals as not being able to expand the octet.

  • Chem? -

    So then it would be all of them except Br right?

  • Chem? -

    Don't P and S have expanded octets?
    For example SF6 and PF5.

  • Chem? -

    Here is something I found that may prove useful.

    http://72.14.205.104/search?q=cache:eeDUwaZtsE8J:student.ccbcmd.edu/~cyau1/ExpandedOctet.pdf+expanded+octet&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=us&ie=UTF-8

  • Chem? -

    In my first response, I believe I was thinking of hybridization. Atoms with no d orbitals can form s and p hybrids but not s, p, and d hybrids (since no d orbitals are there.)

  • Chem? -

    I know I was and that is correct. An expanded octet cannot occur with atoms less than atomic number 10 (neon) because there are no d orbitals. So you are correct; I believe Br is the only one with an atomic number larger than 10. I brought up P and S but those elements ARE greater than 10 AND since they are in the third period, they contain 3d orbitals and extra electrons can fit around them. Therefore, my first response was ok; d orbitals are necessary for hybridization to take place (involving d, s, and p orbitals) AND d orbitals are necessary to accommodate and expanded octet. I hope this helps.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Chem

    How would a Lewis Dot Structure be drawn for CO +1?
  2. chemistry

    how can i tell if a molecule has one of the following features -incomplete octet -expanded shell -odd electron molecule for example BCl3 is incomplete octet but i don't know why also for B when speaking about lewis structures and the …
  3. Chemistry

    SO2 can be drawn as a molecule which satisfies the octet rule (using one double bond and a single bond) or as an expanded octet (using two double bonds). A measurement of the S-O bond distance demonstrates that the two bond lengths …
  4. Chemistry

    I have to write the exact lewis electron dot structure for para xylene C8H10. I tried writing it out but it doesnt work out proerly. C is supposed to have 31 electrons and H is supposed to have 10 totaling 42. i was doing research …
  5. chem

    what are 6 elemts that make up Yellow Gold?
  6. Chemistry

    How would I go about creating a Lewis Dot structure for the Calcium Carbonate and Magnesium Hydroxide?
  7. AP Chem

    A valid Lewis structure of __________ cannot be drawn without violating the octet rule. Answer: BeH2 Why would BeH2 break the octet?
  8. Chemistry

    Identify the true statement about Lewis structures. Select all the correct answers. 1. Hydrogen is usually surrounded by 4 electrons in a valid Lewis structure. 2. A single bond in a Lewis structure represents 2 electrons. 3. A double …
  9. chemistry

    which of the following is true regarding the transition elements?
  10. Chemistry

    In general, do transition metals or main group elements tend to have higher melting points?

More Similar Questions