In the book A Raisin in the Sun, what do you think about George Murchison? Is he a good match for Beneatha? Why/ why not? Please check my answer:
Is this correct: I think George is a very privileged person. He's very lucky. He's finacially well-off. I don't think he's a good match for Bennie because they disagree upon too many things. It's not a healthy relationship.
"Beneatha dislikes his willingness to submit to white culture and forget his African heritage. He challenges the thoughts and feelings of other black people through his arrogance and flair for intellectual competition."
http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/raisin/characters.html
Thanks, I overlooked that on Sparknotes.
Your answer is a good start, but let's go over it and expand on it further.
To determine whether George Murchison is a good match for Beneatha Younger in the book A Raisin in the Sun, it's necessary to consider multiple aspects of their characters and their interactions within the story.
Firstly, you correctly note that George is a privileged person and financially well-off. This is highlighted in the play, where his affluent background and high social status are emphasized. Beneatha, on the other hand, comes from a middle-class African-American family and has aspirations of becoming a doctor. Their differing socioeconomic backgrounds can potentially create a significant gap between them.
Secondly, you mention that George and Beneatha disagree on many things. This is another crucial point in examining their compatibility. Throughout the play, it becomes apparent that their views and interests diverge significantly. Beneatha is characterized by her strong sense of social justice and her desire to reconnect with her African roots. George, on the other hand, seems more concerned with assimilating into the existing white-dominated society and does not appear to share Beneatha's idealistic aspirations.
Finally, you note that their relationship may not be healthy. It is true that their disagreements and differences in values can lead to conflict and tension between them. With their contrasting perspectives and goals in life, they might struggle to find common ground and understanding, which are essential for a healthy and fulfilling relationship.
In summary, while it's ultimately a subjective judgment, based on the analysis provided, it is reasonable to conclude that George Murchison is not a good match for Beneatha Younger in A Raisin in the Sun. Their differing backgrounds, disagreements on various subjects, and potential for an unhealthy dynamic make it challenging for them to build a strong and compatible relationship.