Debate.

posted by .

I'm needing opinions right now.

This is probably one of the stupidest topics (in my opinion) that we've discussed on our debate team, but the argument sparked between the teacher and I. We were talking about people bringing pills to school, and there was one case somewhere in which a student left a pill on his desk, and another student took it and swallowed it without knowing what it was. He died.

The teacher said that upon bringing a pill to school, and leaving it out so that another person can take it is "accidental homicide," therefore the student that brought the pill could be sentenced with murder. That just sounds stupid to me. So I struck back with, "no, it's called suicide. If the idiot was dumb enough to a take a pill like that, then he is responsible for his own actions."

We didn't stay long on this, but it made me mad that the teacher would basically ignore everything I said, refusing to debate, and told me that it was homicide, the end.

So I want some opinions, if anyone has any to spare. Is it murder or is it suicide?

It's neither. This was an accidental death. Both the student who left the pill on his desk and the student who swallowed it were negligent. But I doubt if either student could be indicted for murder. Suicide, by definition, is intentional, and your report of the situation doesn't indicate intentionality.


It's neither. Don't argue with a teacher.

I agree with the above posts, that it was an accidental death, possibly (if anything) leaning towards suicide. More likely, its just a case of stupidity on both parts. Also, I'm annoyed by your teachers response; if this was a debate coach, he/she could have taken the opportunity to explore the issue, ask some other student's opinions, etc. That's definatly what we would do in my debate club. Maybe take a moment to point this out to your teacher - his/her response was definatly unfair, and not in the spirit of debate, that is, expression of differences in opinions!

Even in all that, murder has to be done with "malice aforethought." So there's no way it even could be murder.

(For a better explanation of what that means, check out http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder )

It could be considered manslaughter falling under the category of involuntary manslaughter. I'm no legal expert and I doubt a prosecutor would really pull for that in most situations. I don't even know if it really DOES fall under that. But it seems like it could.

Matt

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Help

    does anyone know anything about bieng a lawyer?
  2. DEBATE+ Many opinions needed+thanks

    I am writing a debate for school and it is about this statement: “The initial cause of WW1 was the assassination of Archduke Francis Ferdinand of Austria-Hungary.” My stance is that it was a trigger but in order for my to write …
  3. Opinion Question: Your opinions are needed please!

    I am writing an essay and our teacher would like for us to include opinions given by other people. Question: How should colleges manage their athletic programs in relation to their academic goals?
  4. Debate

    Can someone give me some tips on how to do well in a debate and possibly win?
  5. AP European History

    Help! What is the appropriate relationship between people and their government?
  6. writing (persuasive essay)

    Hi. I'm in 10th grade and our teacher assigned us a persuasive essay to write in class over a topic that we debated about for the last two weeks. Every team had a different topics (mine was school should start from 11 am. to 5 pm), …
  7. math(Ms.Sue)

    5 students are trying out for the debate team. There are 3 available spots for the team.How many combinations of teams can the debate team make My answer is 15 am i right?
  8. Debate English

    In a debate, after the opposing team poses a question, can our team just stand up and answer or do we have to wait until someone tells us that we are allowed to answer?
  9. English

    Welcome to the English debate. I'd like all of you to take part in this debate. The MC will preside over the debate. I'd like you, the speakers, to come to the front with desks and chairs and be seated on your chairs facing your classmates. …
  10. math

    A school debate team has 4 girls and 6 boys. A total of 4 of the team members will be chosen to participate in the district debate. What is the probability that 2 girls and 2 boys will be selected?

More Similar Questions