History

posted by .

Why was slavery a paradox?


I don't understand the word 'paradox' very well, even though I looked it up and it is defined as "a self-contradiction". Please help, I think the answer might have something to do with a quote I found: "Democratic liberty exists solely because we have slaves . . . freedom is not possible without slavery." Obviously that qoute sounds pretty ridiculous and self-contradictory!

Thank you for using the Jiskha Homework Help Forum. True, the dictionary may not convey the true meaning of paradox. You can, however, understand better through examples. Here are some examples:

1. http://www.basicincome.com/bp/egsofparadox.htm

2. http://www.antimoon.com/words/paradox-n.htm


Paradox: a statement whose two parts seem contradictory yet make sense with more thought. Christ used paradox in his teaching: "They have ears but hear not." Or in ordinary conversation, we might use a paradox, "Deep down he's really very shallow." Paradox attracts the reader's or the listener's attention and gives emphasis.


Your quote should be taken in context. I suspect it's the words of a Southerner shortly before the Civil War. To him, his freedom was the right of white men to make a good living. He believed that owning slaves to do the labor was necessary for his freedom and well-being. Slaves weren't considered real people, so freedom didn't apply to them.


The main context of the paradox can be seen in the last part of the quote that "freedom is not possible without slavery." The paradox come to be with the point that
southerners saw the acquisition of slaves as personal freedom, the freedom to have a better way of life. But by having themselves this freedom, they take freedom away from another, the slaves. That, I think, is what the paradox of slavery is: enslaving people for freedom.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. paradox

    which of the following is not a paradox? a. It was "darkness visible."- Milton b. If you love someone, let her go. c. The more things change, the more they stay the same. d. Pretty is as pretty does. I would say d but I am not 100%
  2. Gifted+Talented English-(Figurative Speech Poetry)

    Our assignment is to write a poem on each of the types of figurative speech. simile metaphor synecdoche metonymy personification apostrophe hyperbole understatement irony paradox I have completed every one of them except understatement …
  3. analogy or paradox

    is the following analogy paradox or irony i think its analogy 1)Then, the ends of the torches were flung hissing into the water, and went out, as if it were all over with him
  4. analogy inference paradox

    The room was but small, and clients seemed to have had a habit of bscking up against the wall: the wall especially opposite to Mr.Jaggers's chair, being greasy with shoulders its either analogy inference or paradox i think its inference
  5. english

    is " but I will not allow anyone to succeed hanging clouds over me" a metaphor or paradox or is it something else?
  6. English

    I am still looking for an example of a paradox. Would the statement, "I had no identity" be a paradox?
  7. English

    The excerpt has an example of what literary device?
  8. Language Arts - Please Check Answer

    Please help me with the following question: A paradox is a literary device often used to A. emphasize or make readers think about important ideas. B. provide hints or clues about events that occur later in a story. C. explain a character’s …
  9. africa

    explain the american paradox of freedom and slavery
  10. MAth

    Determine when the Hamilton method gives an Alabama paradox and who lost the representative. Increase the committee size by one seat at a time, starting from an 8-member committee. Given: City A, City B, and City C are cooperating …

More Similar Questions