posted by .

7. Suppose there are two possible income distributions in a society of ten people. In the first distribution, nine people have incomes of $30,000 and one person has an income of $10,000. In the second distribution, all ten people have incomes of $25,000.
a. If the society had the first income distribution, what would be the utilitarian argument for redistributing income?
The nine individuals have a higher utility than the one individual with the income of $10,000. So if for example a dollar was taken from the rich and given to the poor the utility of society as a whole would increase. This is because the poor person would have a higher utility from the dollar gained than the fall in utility from the rich people.

b. Which income distribution would Rawls consider more equitable? Explain.
I would think that the second distribution would be more equitable since Rawls would want equality.
c. Which income distribution would Nozick consider more equitable? Explain.

I would think that Nozick would consider the first distribution more equitable. Since Nozick would want individuals to a fair playing field but not concerned about the resulting distribution of income. So the second distribution of income is equal so the only option left is the first one.

What is your question regarding this situation?

I would like to know if my responses for each of the 3 questions is correct.

Your bottom line answers for Utilitarians and Rawls are correct. However, both views have exceptions which you should note in your final answer.

Nozick, on the other hand, is not bothered by income inequality as long as the process for generating the distribution is "fair." So, Nozick would not "prefer" either distribution. However, he would not advocate a redistribution process that moves from distribution a to distribution b.

Bottom line. your are on the right track; but your arguments need to be much more fully developed; certainly more than a single sentence for each.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. economics

    income total spending $10,000 $10,000 20,000 18,000 50,000 35,000 100,000 60,000 If a sales tax of ten percent is levied on all purchases, calculate A. amoust of sales tax paid at each income level and B. the fraction f income paid …
  2. Economics

    6. The chapter uses the analogy of a "leaky bucket" to explain one constraint on the redistribution of income. a. What elements of the U.S. system for redistributing income create the leaks in the bucket?
  3. science

    one way of describing population distribution is the number of people per area, but it can also refer to a)the hybridization composition of the people b) the age distribution of the people c) the political composition of the people …
  4. Pre-Calculus

    .  Margaret is planning to invest up to $22,000 in certificates of deposit at City Bank and People’s Bank.  She wants to invest at least $2,000 but no more than $14,000 at City Bank.  People’s Bank does not insure more than …
  5. economics

    If the society had the first income distribution, what would be the utilitarian argument for redistribution income?
  6. economics

    Explain why the productivity standard for the distribution of income entails rewarding people based on their contribution to society s total output. Why does the productivity standard typically fail to yield an equal distribution of …
  7. Statistics

    A random sample of customer incomes yields a mean income of $35000 with a standard deviation of $4500. Assume that the distribution of the incomes in normal. What income range would include 90% of the most popular incomes?
  8. math

    distribution of adjust gross income in individual federal income tax returns shows: Income: 30-74, 75-199, more than 200 Probability: 0.315, 0.180, 0.031 1. What is the probability that a randomly chosen return shows an adjusted gross …
  9. Math, Please Help!

    If 99 people had a mean income of $12,000, how much is the mean income increased by the addition of a single income of $200,000?
  10. economics

    A recently released Gallup survey confirms the fears of many who oppose government-promoted gambling: the poorest among us are contributing much more to lottery revenues than those with higher incomes. The poll found that people who …

More Similar Questions