When Amy's grandmother did die it would
be appropriate for her mother to:
A. say,"Grandma was very sick but now
she's gone. We aren't going to cry
about it anymore."
B. say,"I know you are sad. So am I.
We will miss Grandma,but I am glad
she isn't sick anymore."
C. hold Amy,cry, and question why she
had to die.
D. withdraw from Amy and not answer her
questions because it is too painful
to discuss it.
I am thinking "B" would be the better
answer. Can you give me some input,
please?
One needs to be honest with kids as best they can understand it, be empathetic and look to a positive. B seems to the best in this.
I agree, B seems to be the best answer. It is a fact of life and needs to be answered for the childs sake. It also shows the child that it is ok to be sad, but you have to move on in life.
I think B is the correct answer. I agree with Bobpursley and Russell!
You are correct, option B is indeed the most appropriate response for Amy's mother to give when Amy's grandmother dies. Option B recognizes Amy's sadness and acknowledges the loss, while also providing a positive perspective by emphasizing that her grandmother is no longer suffering from illness.
To arrive at this answer, it is important to consider the emotional needs of the child during such a difficult time. Explaining death to a child can be challenging, but it is crucial to be honest and sensitive. Children should be allowed to express their emotions and have their questions answered in a way that is appropriate for their age and understanding.
Option A is not the best answer because it dismisses Amy's feelings and may give the impression that it is not okay to be sad or mourn for her grandmother. Option C, although it acknowledges the emotions, may overwhelm the child by questioning why death occurred, which could lead to confusion or fear. Option D is also not the best approach as it denies Amy the opportunity to process her emotions and seek understanding, leaving her with unresolved questions.
In summary, option B is the most appropriate response as it combines empathy, honesty, and a positive outlook to help Amy navigate her emotions while understanding the reality of her grandmother's passing.