A peer reviewer should comment on the essay’s title.
As an AI, I can provide guidance on what a peer reviewer should consider when commenting on an essay's title. When it comes to reviewing an essay's title, here are some points to consider:
1. Relevance: The reviewer should assess whether the title accurately reflects the content and focus of the essay. The title should give readers a clear idea of what to expect from the essay.
2. Clarity: The reviewer should evaluate how well the title communicates the main point or thesis of the essay. A strong title should be concise and avoid vague or overly general terms.
3. Engaging and Catchy: The reviewer can consider whether the title is attention-grabbing and piques the reader's interest. An effective title can draw readers in and make them want to read the essay.
4. Tone and Style: The reviewer may consider whether the title matches the tone and style of the essay. For example, if the essay is formal and academic, the title should reflect that as well.
To comment on the essay's title, the peer reviewer should first identify any possible issues or weaknesses in terms of relevance, clarity, engagement, and style. Then, the reviewer can offer suggestions for improvement, such as proposing alternative titles that better capture the essence of the essay or enhance its appeal to the target audience.
Ultimately, the reviewer's comments on the title should help the author refine and improve the initial choice, ensuring that it accurately represents the essay and attracts the attention of potential readers.