Choose two famous individuals to research that lived between 1820 and 1860. Keep in mind—your
famous Americans MUST have DIFFERENT opinions on the SAME topic.
Can you help me choose the two different individuals? Here's a list that I can choose from:
Andrew Jackson (Native American Rights)
Osceola (Native American Rights)
Winnfield Scott (Native American Rights)
Henry David Thoreau (Civil Disobedience)
James K. Polk (American Mexican War or Civil Disobedience)
Elizabeth Cady Stanton (Women’s Rights)
Josephine Marshall Jewell Dodge (Women’s Rights)
Sojourner Truth (Women’s Rights or Fugitive Slave Act)
Millard Fillmore (Fugitive Slave Act)
Frederick Douglass (Slavery)
John Brown (Slavery)
Start with a topic that interests you. Then research to find the opinions of the people who had different opinions on this subject.
The first two names on your list had different opinions about Native American rights.
Thank you! I'll stick with the first two.
You're welcome. :-)
To choose two famous individuals who lived between 1820 and 1860 and had different opinions on the same topic, you can first consider their respective views on each topic. Here's a breakdown of their stances:
1. Native American Rights:
a. Andrew Jackson: Jackson is known for his controversial policies towards Native Americans, such as the Indian Removal Act of 1830, which forced the relocation of Native American tribes. He was known for his support of westward expansion and the assimilation of Native Americans into American society.
b. Osceola: Osceola was a Native American leader of the Seminole tribe who opposed the Indian Removal Act and the forced relocation of Native Americans. He is remembered for his resistance against the encroachment of Native American lands by American settlers.
2. Civil Disobedience:
a. Henry David Thoreau: Thoreau was an American transcendentalist and writer who believed in the power of individual conscience and civil disobedience. He famously protested against unjust laws and governments, as described in his essay "Civil Disobedience."
b. James K. Polk: Polk, the 11th President of the United States, focused on manifest destiny and the expansion of US territory. While he supported the American Mexican War, his views on civil disobedience are not as prominent in historical records.
3. Women's Rights:
a. Elizabeth Cady Stanton: Stanton was a leading figure in the women's suffrage movement and co-authored the Declaration of Sentiments, which called for equality between men and women. She advocated for women's right to vote and challenged traditional gender roles.
b. Josephine Marshall Jewell Dodge: Dodge was an advocate for women's rights and worked alongside Stanton. While she was not as widely known as Stanton, she played a vital role in promoting women's suffrage and equal rights.
4. Slavery:
a. Frederick Douglass: Douglass was an influential African-American abolitionist, writer, and speaker. He campaigned against the institution of slavery, advocating for equal rights and freedom for all enslaved individuals.
b. John Brown: Brown was an American abolitionist who believed in the use of armed insurrection to end slavery. He became infamous for his raid on Harper's Ferry in 1859, aiming to incite a slave rebellion.
Now, based on their different opinions on the same topic, you can choose two individuals of your interest to research further.