If the Court decides to recognize a constitutional right to die (a right not currently recognized by the Court and not explicitly in the Bill of Rights) and to require the states to recognize this right, what doctrine of incorporation would this reflect?


A. Total incorporation doctrine


B. Select incorporation doctrine


C. Both a and b


D. None of the above

I think it's D.

To determine which doctrine of incorporation would be reflected if the Court decides to recognize a constitutional right to die, we need to understand what the incorporation doctrine is and how it applies.

The incorporation doctrine refers to the process by which certain provisions of the Bill of Rights are applied to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause. It ensures that individual rights protected by the Bill of Rights also apply to state governments.

Now, considering the question at hand, if the Court decides to recognize a constitutional right to die and requires the states to recognize this right, it means that the Court is extending this right to the states. This would be a form of incorporation, as the Court is applying a constitutional right to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment.

Based on this understanding, the correct answer is B. Select incorporation doctrine. This doctrine holds that only some of the provisions of the Bill of Rights are applied to the states, rather than all of them. In this case, the Court would be selectively incorporating the right to die into the states' constitutional framework.

Therefore, the correct answer to the question is B. Select incorporation doctrine.

Actually, the correct answer is D. None of the above. The doctrine of incorporation refers to the process by which the Supreme Court applies the provisions of the Bill of Rights to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause. However, the question does not involve the incorporation of any specific rights, as it is asking about the recognition of a new right not currently recognized by the Court or explicitly in the Bill of Rights.