How does the poem(Ode on a Grecian Urn) express both the positive and negative sides of the search for beauty?

To analyze how the poem "Ode on a Grecian Urn" by John Keats expresses both the positive and negative sides of the search for beauty, we need to closely examine the text. By doing a close reading of the poem, we can identify specific lines, imagery, and themes that convey these aspects. Here's a step-by-step breakdown of how you can perform this analysis yourself:

1. Read the poem: Obtain a copy of the poem "Ode on a Grecian Urn" by John Keats and read it carefully. This will provide you with a general understanding of the poem and its overall structure.

2. Identify positive expressions of beauty: Look for lines or stanzas that depict beauty in a positive light. Note any descriptions that evoke feelings of awe, admiration, or joy. Keats often emphasizes the timeless nature of beauty in the urn, suggesting that it can transcend the limitations of human existence. For example, lines like "Heard melodies are sweet, but those unheard / Are sweeter" highlight the allure of the unknown and the imagination.

3. Identify negative expressions of beauty: Look for instances where the poem presents a more negative aspect of the search for beauty. Keats hints at the limitations and pitfalls of pursuing an idealized beauty that is detached from reality. For example, lines such as "Bold Lover, never, never canst thou kiss" and "Fair youth, beneath the trees, thou canst not leave / Thy song" reflect the inability to fully experience and engage with the beauty frozen on the urn.

4. Analyze symbolic elements: Analyze the symbolic imagery used in the poem, particularly related to the urn itself. Consider how the physical characteristics of the urn, such as its static nature and frozen scenes, contribute to the exploration of the positive and negative aspects of beauty. The permanence and immutability of the artwork on the urn can be seen as both a representation of transcendent beauty and a limitation that lacks the vitality of life.

5. Consider the speaker's perspective: The speaker's attitude towards the urn and its depictions of beauty can offer insights into the positive and negative dimensions. Determine if the speaker seems enchanted or disillusioned by the urn's frozen art. This might involve analyzing their tone, word choices, and shifts in perspective throughout the poem.

6. Form conclusions: Based on your analysis of the poem's language, imagery, and themes, draw conclusions about how "Ode on a Grecian Urn" expresses both the positive and negative sides of the search for beauty. Be sure to support your conclusions with specific evidence from the poem.

Remember, the process of analyzing any poem involves subjective interpretation. Make sure to substantiate your claims with textual evidence and use your own critical thinking skills to develop a well-supported analysis.

Make sure you read it ... several times. Once is not enough.

http://www.bartleby.com/101/625.html

THEN ... make note of every line in which you find "positive sides" and every line in which you find "negative sides" -- and put those line numbers in different columns.

Go back and reread all the positive-sides lines. What do these lines have in common with each other?

Go back and reread all the negative-sides lines. what do these lines have in common with each other?

Let us know what you come up with.