Posted by Ann (: on Friday, October 12, 2012 at 7:00am.
How to write a fallacy essay
. Write purpose of the article including name, title, author, and say if you think the article is strong or not
. We live in a polarizing society, so perhaps itís inevitable that our experience of inequality should be polarized, too.
Josh Haner/The New York Times
Go to Columnist Page Ľ
David Brooksís Blog
The intellectual, cultural and scientific findings that land on the columnistís desk nearly every day.
Go the Blog Ľ
Times Topic: Income Inequality
Related in Opinion
Room For Debate: Rising Wealth Inequality: Should We Care?
Readers shared their thoughts on this article.
Read All Comments (545) Ľ
In the first place, there is what you might call Blue Inequality. This is the kind experienced in New York City, Los Angeles, Boston, San Francisco, Seattle, Dallas, Houston and the District of Columbia. In these places, you see the top 1 percent of earners zooming upward, amassing more income and wealth. The economists Jon Bakija, Adam Cole and Bradley Heim have done the most authoritative research on who these top 1 percenters are.
Roughly 31 percent started or manage nonfinancial businesses. About 16 percent are doctors, 14 percent are in finance, 8 percent are lawyers, 5 percent are engineers and about 2 percent are in sports, entertainment or the media.
If you live in or around these big cities, you see stores and entire neighborhoods catering to the top 1 percent. You see a shift in social norms. Up until 1970 or so, a chief executive would have been embarrassed to take home more than $20 million. But now there is no shame, and top compensation zooms upward.
You also see the superstar effect that economists have noticed in the income data. Within each profession, the top performers are now paid much better than the merely good or average performers.
If you live in these big cities, you see people similar to yourself, who may have gone to the same college, who are earning much more while benefiting from low tax rates, wielding disproportionate political power, gaining in prestige and contributing seemingly little to the social good. That is the experience of Blue Inequality.
Then there is what you might call Red Inequality. This is the kind experienced in Scranton, Des Moines, Naperville, Macon, Fresno, and almost everywhere else. In these places, the crucial inequality is not between the top 1 percent and the bottom 99 percent. Itís between those with a college degree and those without. Over the past several decades, the economic benefits of education have steadily risen. In 1979, the average college graduate made 38 percent more than the average high school graduate, according to the Fed chairman, Ben Bernanke. Now the average college graduate makes more than 75 percent more.
Moreover, college graduates have become good at passing down advantages to their children. If you are born with parents who are college graduates, your odds of getting through college are excellent. If you are born to high school grads, your odds are terrible.
In fact, the income differentials understate the chasm between college and high school grads. In the 1970s, high school and college grads had very similar family structures. Today, college grads are much more likely to get married, they are much less likely to get divorced and they are much, much less likely to have a child out of wedlock.
Today, college grads are much less likely to smoke than high school grads, they are less likely to be obese, they are more likely to be active in their communities, they have much more social trust, they speak many more words to their children at home.
Some research suggests that college grads have much bigger friendship networks than high school grads. The social divide is even starker than the income divide.
These two forms of inequality exist in modern America. They are related but different. Over the past few months, attention has shifted almost exclusively to Blue Inequality.
Thatís because the protesters and media people who cover them tend to live in or near the big cities, where the top 1 percent is so evident. Thatís because the liberal arts majors like to express their disdain for the shallow business and finance majors who make all the money. Thatís because it is easier to talk about the inequality of stock options than it is to talk about inequalities of family structure, child rearing patterns and educational attainment. Thatís because many people are wedded to the notion that our problems are caused by an oppressive privileged class that perpetually keeps its boot stomped on the neck of the common man.
But the fact is that Red Inequality is much more important. The zooming wealth of the top 1 percent is a problem, but itís not nearly as big a problem as the tens of millions of Americans who have dropped out of high school or college. Itís not nearly as big a problem as the 40 percent of children who are born out of wedlock. Itís not nearly as big a problem as the nationís stagnant human capital, its stagnant social mobility and the disorganized social fabric for the bottom 50 percent.
If your ultimate goal is to reduce inequality, then you should be furious at the doctors, bankers and C.E.O.ís. If your goal is to expand opportunity, then you have a much bigger and different agenda.
A version of this op-ed appeared in print on November 1, 2011, on page A27 of the New York edition with the headline: The Wrong Inequality.
SIGN IN TO E-MAIL
†Get 50% Off The New York Times & Free All Digital Access.
- English1C - Writeacher, Friday, October 12, 2012 at 7:43am
Please note that we don't do students' assignments for them. Be sure to go back into your textbook or use a good search engine. http://hanlib.sou.edu/searchtools/
Once YOU have attempted to complete YOUR assignment, please re-post and let us know what you think. Then someone here will be happy to comment on your thinking.
Answer this Question
English1C - I need help writing a fallacy essay about The Wrong InequalityBack ...
PHI 103 - "The Senator wants to cut spending on police. I guess she doesn't ...
critical thinking - The reason the auto industry is such a mess is the ...
critical thinking - I donít care if he has a PhD from Harvard! Heís a Mormon ...
critical thinking - The Presidentís agenda has been derailed by out of touch ...
ct. - Can someone please check my answers and tell me if I have matched these (...
critical thinking - From a politician asked by reporter about an alleged ethics...
English+Essay - I have to write an essay, but I have no idea how to start it. It...
English essay - I have to write an essay on " Human beings have unlimited ...
Social St.!!!ASAP!!!! - If I am writing an essay what should I include for my ...