In his autobiography Timebends, Arthur Miller writes that "the real story" of the Salem witch trials is to be found in "the breaking of charity" within a human community. Write a brief essay explaning what you think Miller means by this interesting statement, and suuport your opinion with evidence from the text. Conclude your essay with your reflection on whether "the breaking of charity" could destory a community today.
Please tell me what the hell its asking. PLEASE I suck at analyzing and I don't understand at all.!!!!!!!!
The breaking of charity in this situation means suspicions, rumors, and unfounded accusations can ruin relationships within a community. One critic compares the Crucible's poisonous aura with that of the U.S. in the McCarthy era.
This site may help you.
http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/crucible/
Ms.Sue
What else? can you answer the question please? I need more and I need the answer to it.
how did rumors ruin the community in the play?
I understand that you may find the passage from Arthur Miller's autobiography, Timebends, challenging to comprehend and analyze. Let's break it down together to help you understand the meaning behind Miller's statement.
First, let's focus on the key phrase: "the breaking of charity within a human community." In this context, the term "charity" refers to the concept of goodwill, empathy, and kindness among community members. Miller suggests that the root cause of the Salem witch trials, a historical event he extensively studied and wrote about in his play, The Crucible, lies in the breakdown of these positive qualities within the community.
To understand Miller's viewpoint, it is essential to examine the events of the Salem witch trials. The trials were characterized by accusations, mistrust, and the unjust persecution of individuals as witches. Miller argues that this breakdown of charity, or the loss of community spirit and unity, led to a toxic environment where fear and self-interest prevailed over empathy and cooperation.
In Timebends, Miller explores the destructive consequences that occur when charity is shattered within a community. He introduces the characters' motivations, such as personal grievances, envy, and resentment, which culminate in false accusations and a lack of compassion for others. By focusing on these aspects, Miller suggests that the community's downfall was not solely a result of superstition or religious fanaticism but stemmed from the erosion of genuine charity.
To gather evidence to support your analysis, you might consider revisiting Timebends and The Crucible. Look for instances where characters display a lack of charity towards each other, whether through spreading rumors, making false accusations, or turning a blind eye to injustice. Explore how these actions contribute to the overall breakdown of the community.
Now, let's consider the relevance of "the breaking of charity" within a community today. Miller's statement raises the question of whether such a breakdown could still devastate a community in modern times. To reflect on this, think about instances in contemporary society, both in history and in current events, where a lack of charity has had dire consequences on communities. This could include instances of discrimination, scapegoating, or the disregard for others' well-being.
Additionally, consider how fostering charity within a community can be essential for maintaining harmony, empathy, and social stability. Reflect on real-life examples where acts of kindness and understanding have united communities and helped them overcome challenging circumstances.
In your essay's conclusion, share your thoughts on whether "the breaking of charity" could still destroy a community today. Analyze the potential consequences based on your evidence and observations. Consider the importance of fostering and promoting charity within our own communities to ensure their well-being and resilience.
Remember, it is always helpful to support your analysis with specific examples and quotes from the text to strengthen your arguments. Good luck with your essay!