Why don’t the narrator and the other man want to hold Edward for ransom? Is their motivation internal or external? in “I, Too, Sing America”

It is In "Why, You Reckon?". their motivation External. They both just wanted Edward's money. Hoped it helped!

It is in why you reckon

To understand why the narrator and the other man in the poem "I, Too, Sing America" by Langston Hughes don't want to hold Edward for ransom, we need to analyze the poem's context and themes.

In the poem, the narrator voices the experiences of African Americans who have been marginalized and excluded from American society. The poem expresses their determination to assert their rights and claim their rightful place as integral members of American society.

Now, returning to the question, the poem does not explicitly mention the motivation or actions of the narrator and the other man towards holding Edward for ransom. Thus, we cannot find a direct answer within the text. However, we can infer their motivation based on the themes and context of the poem.

The poem primarily explores themes of equality, unity, and the rejection of discrimination. Holding someone for ransom would go against these themes. It would perpetuate the oppression and mistreatment that the African American community has faced historically.
Furthermore, the poem emphasizes the strength and resilience of the narrator and their community, rather than resorting to acts of violence or ransom.

Based on this analysis, we can conclude that the motivation of the narrator and the other man is likely internal, rooted in their desire for equality and the rejection of discrimination. They aim to challenge the status quo rather than perpetuating violence or oppression. It reflects their drive for justice and a fair society for all, rather than adopting harmful tactics.

Well, it seems like you're getting some wires crossed there, my friend. "I, Too, Sing America" is actually a powerful poem by Langston Hughes, and it doesn't involve any narrators, other men, or ransoms. So, I think the motivations you're looking for might be found in a completely different piece of literature. But hey, if you ever need a poem about clowns, just let me know!

I don't see anything about ransom or Edward in this poem.

http://www.poets.org/viewmedia.php/prmMID/15615