Did the quebec separatists had a reasonable complaint with federal government and rest of Canada?

Would that be true because they not respecting their culture. They only giving importance to their own culture and not caring about French.

That is a matter of opinion. You're opinion is probably what a majority of Canadians believe.

ms. sue you also think same or not?

I agree with you.

i saying this because if my culture not being respected then i not take step to violence but i probably support those people because i want my culture to spread , i want it to be given importance and want it offically accepted if that make any sense.

The problem for the Quebecois is which culture they accept. Many of them feel much more involved with the native French Quebecois culture than they do with the Canadian culture. It seems to me that they've accomplished some of their goals by making Canada bilingual and electing members of Parliament.

Yes i agree with that and just learned that word bilingual today and it mean two languages right?

The question you have raised will make excellent debates in schools, among politicians, and among provinces. Unfortunately there is no black and white single answer. It depends on who gives the opinion, and probably where the person resides.

As Ms Sue said, it is a matter of personal opinion.

As you probably know, Quebec is the only province in Canada which has French (only) as its official language. New Brunswick adopts two official languages, and the remaining provinces and territories have English as the official language.

It is obvious that the language majority of each province would not want to see the language being eroded.

This is especially true in Quebec, where the "nationalists", as they call themselves instead of separatists, claim that French speaking minorities should be protected from the sea of English speakers in North America. Without the required protection, French will all but disappear from North America, as it did in Lousiana a century ago. Today, we still recognize the French culture from place names like Lafayette, Baton Rouge, etc.

There are "colonies" of French speaking population in various parts of Canada, such as Manitoba, Sudbury, and many parts of Eastern Ontario. It has been feared that the French language and culture outside of Quebec will disappear if insufficient protection is provided by the Canadian. Protection could imply services in the French language, schools, health-care, judicial system, etc.

The Official Languages Act was one big step in the right direction. Whether enough has been, or will be done is obviously debated among politicians.

To grasp the subject well, it will be necessary to understand quite a few of the historical and political aspects related to Canadian history.

Thank you for bringing up an interesting discussion.

Thank you very much MathMate for your input =D

I think him also. His perspective as a Canadian is welcomed!

To determine whether Quebec separatists had a reasonable complaint with the federal government and the rest of Canada, we need to consider several factors. The issue of cultural preservation and respect is indeed one of the key concerns raised by Quebec separatists.

Here's how you can approach this question:

1. Evaluate the history: When trying to understand the grievances of Quebec separatists, it's important to consider the historical context. Quebec has a distinct French-speaking culture within Canada, which has faced periods of assimilation and marginalization in the past.

2. Look at language policies: One significant issue for Quebecois separatists has been the preservation and promotion of the French language. Historically, there have been tensions between Quebec and the federal government over language policies, such as those related to bilingualism and the use of French in federal institutions.

3. Assess representation and autonomy: Another concern raised by Quebec separatists is the perceived lack of political representation and autonomy within the federal framework. The desire for more control over their own affairs, including their cultural and linguistic policies, has been a driving force behind the separatist movement.

4. Consider economic factors: Economic disparities have also contributed to the separatist sentiment in Quebec. There have been debates about the distribution of wealth and resources between the federal government and Quebec, which some separatists argue has not been fair.

5. Weigh regional and national interests: While Quebec separatists highlight their cultural and linguistic distinctiveness, it's important to remember that they represent a specific regional perspective within Canada. The federal government also has the responsibility to balance the interests and needs of all provinces and territories.

Ultimately, whether Quebec separatists' complaints are reasonable is subjective and can depend on individual perspectives. Some may argue that cultural preservation and representation are valid concerns, while others may prioritize national unity and the importance of a strong federal government.

By considering these factors and engaging in a balanced evaluation of the historical, cultural, political, and economic aspects, you can develop a more informed understanding of the Quebec separatist movement and form your own opinion on the reasonableness of their complaints.