REASONING Tara says that 1/2 of a salad is always the same amount. Lynn says that it could be different amounts, depending on how large the salad is. Who is correct and why?

Amount/2 would vary depending on the original amount.

Lynn is correct. 1/2 of a small salad is less than 1/2 of a large salad

Lynn is correct because 1/2 of a tiny salad is less than 1/2 of a big salad

To determine who is correct, let's break down the reasoning of each person.

Tara's Reasoning:
Tara states that 1/2 of a salad is always the same amount. This implies that regardless of the size of the salad, cutting it into halves would result in equal portions.

Lynn's Reasoning:
Lynn argues that the amount of 1/2 of a salad could be different depending on how large the salad is. This suggests that the size of the salad plays a role in determining the quantity of 1/2 of the salad.

To resolve this, let's consider an example:
Imagine we have a small salad that can fit in a small bowl and a large salad that requires a big plate. If we divide the small salad into halves, we might end up with two relatively equal portions. On the other hand, if we divide the large salad into halves, each half might still be more substantial than the individual portions of the small salad.

From this example, we can conclude that Lynn is correct. The amount of 1/2 of the salad can indeed be different depending on the size of the salad. So, Lynn's reasoning is more accurate in this case.