Posted by **rfvv** on Monday, June 13, 2011 at 8:11am.

1. When I arrived at the station, the train had alrready left.

2. When I arrived at the station, he had been waiting for me for half an hour.

3. When I arrived at the station, he had waited for me for half an hour.

(Are they all grammatical? Which expressions should I use, #2 or #3? Thank you for your help.)

- English -
**Writeacher**, Monday, June 13, 2011 at 8:48am
All are correct, but I'd use #2 rather than #3.

The progressive tense in #2 gives the sense of time passing until "I" arrived. In #3, it's not clear if he "had waited" (and then left) or if he "had waited" and was still waiting.

- English -
**Albert**, Friday, February 7, 2014 at 4:10am
1 and 2 are acceptable; 3 is ambiguous.

## Answer This Question

## Related Questions

- Math - The table shows the times a train left Austin and arrived in San Antonio ...
- English - Can you please see if everything is correct? Thank you. 1) She said ...
- english - Can someone check my work for me, please. 1.Yesterday he was very busy...
- Math I am lost! - Tom travelled to the train station at 60 mph and arrived 1 ...
- Algebra 2 (Distance Problem) - A train leaves Union Station for Central Station...
- math - One train left the station and traveled toward its destination at a speed...
- Math - An airplane traveled a distance d in t hours, where r>1, and arrived ...
- English - Can you check if my corrections are OK? Thank you. 1) He told her that...
- english - 27. When they …. in Shanghai, they .… amazed. (A) arrive / will be (B...
- physics - A train starts from station A at 1pm and reaches station B at 3 pm, ...

More Related Questions