I have to do a paragraph on how the Latin American revolutions were better then the American Revolution. [ IN my opinnion, they weren't, but my teacher gave me this topic]

Question

I have to do a paragraph on how the Latin American revolutions were better then the American Revolution. [ IN my opinnion, they weren't, but my teacher gave me this topic]

Could someone give me some reasons for why they were better?

Thanks

-Allyson

Answer 1

Well, they did not have to call on France for help.

I think (not sure) they all eliminated slavery.

Answer 2

Consider the differences in the lives of the people prior to the revolutions.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_American_wars_of_independence

Answer 3

Certainly, I can help provide you with some reasons why some people might argue that the Latin American revolutions were better than the American Revolution. Remember that these points are not representing my opinion, but rather presenting possibilities for your paragraph:

1. Wider scope: One possible reason is that the Latin American revolutions had a broader impact, as they involved multiple countries across the region. This led to broader changes and had long-lasting effects on governments, societies, and economies.

2. Overcoming colonial rule: Unlike the American Revolution, which resulted in independence from Britain, the Latin American revolutions were aimed at overthrowing oppressive colonial powers such as Spain and Portugal. This could be seen as a more significant achievement since it involved breaking free from centuries of foreign rule.

3. Social change: The Latin American revolutions often coincided with movements for social equality and land reform. Some argue that these revolutions had more profound impacts on addressing social injustices and promoting equality among different social classes, whereas the American Revolution mainly focused on political independence.

4. Cultural resurgence: The Latin American revolutions sparked a renewed interest and pride in indigenous cultures and heritage. This emphasis on cultural identity and diversity can be seen as a positive outcome of these revolutions, setting them apart from the American Revolution, which primarily focused on embracing and adapting existing British institutions.

Remember, it is crucial to present counterarguments even if you don't personally agree with them. In your paragraph, you can address these points and then explain why you believe the American Revolution was nonetheless significant or hold any other perspective you deem appropriate based on your research and analysis of the topic.