You are writing to a reader who favors a different solution than the one you recommend. Which of the following is MOST likely to persuade the reader? (Points: 5)
Describe your reader's solution first, explain why it won't work, and then go on to describe your own solution.
Ignore your opponent's solution and just concentrate on your own.
Describe your own solution first. Then briefly say why your reader's idea won't work.
Go back and forth between solutions, contrasting step by step.
I think the answer is D but is not sure
I agree.
Thank you!
You're welcome.
You are correct, the most effective way to persuade a reader who favors a different solution is option D: Go back and forth between solutions, contrasting step by step. This approach allows you to objectively present both solutions side by side, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each. By directly addressing and comparing the solutions, you can effectively show why your recommended solution is superior.
To implement this approach, start by describing your own solution first, explaining the benefits and reasons why it is the best option. Then, transition to discussing your reader's solution, acknowledging its merits and discussing why it may not be as effective as your recommended solution. By presenting both solutions in a balanced manner and using logical reasoning to explain why your solution is more preferable, you increase the chances of persuading your reader.
It is important to address your opponent's solution directly and give it due consideration, as this shows respect for their perspective. Ignoring their solution (option B) might come across as dismissive or disrespectful, potentially alienating the reader. Similarly, if you describe your reader's solution first and explain why it won't work (option A), the reader may focus on the critique rather than being open to considering alternatives. By presenting your solution first and then explaining the drawbacks of your reader's idea, you maintain their interest and engagement throughout the persuasive piece.