Posted by chelsea salam on Saturday, February 5, 2011 at 4:29pm.
iM having a really hard time answering/understanding a question.
this is the question.
How is the conflict between Arthur and Frank a prelude to a larger conflict between Frank and the neighborhood? Write a paragraph speculating about what you think is the underlying but unstated conflict in Thunder on Sycamore Street. Support your ideas with details from the excerpt.
Can someone please help! i have to answer the question tomorrow.here is the story. its called Thunder on Sycamore Street. Its short please helppp
Frank (to Clarice). Where's that sitter?
Clarice. It's not time yet. Take it easy, Frank.
[Frank gets up from the table, goes over to a box of cigars on top of the TV set, and lights one. Clarice and Roger watch him silently.]
Clarice. Aren't you going to have some dessert, Frank? There's some cherry pie left.
Frank. I'll have it later. [He puffs on the cigar.]
Roger (low). I'm sorry, Dad.
Frank (turning). Well, it's about time you learned some respect, d'you hear me? If I want you to know something I'll tell it to you.
Roger (softly). Okay . . .
Clarice (quickly). Have some pie, honey. I heated it special.
[Frank goes to the table and sits down. He puts the cigar down and Clarice begins to cut him some pie.]
Clarice. How late do you think we'll be, Frank?
Frank. I don't know.
Clarice. Do you think I ought to pack a thermos of hot coffee? It's going to be chilly.
Frank. Might not be a bad idea.
[Frank now begins to show the first signs of being excited about the evening. He speaks, almost to himself.]
Frank. Boy, I can't wait till I see his face. The nerve of him. The absolute nerve. (Grinning) What d'you think he'll do when we all-
Clarice (looking at Roger). Frank . . .
Frank (as Roger stares). Oh, yeah, go ahead, Rog. You can turn on your program.
Roger. Gee thanks, Dad.
[He jumps up, goes to the TV set and turns it on. Frank and Clarice watch him get settled in front of TV set. We hear dialogue from set faintly. Roger watches in background, enraptured.]
Frank (quietly). What are they saying on the block?
Clarice. I didn't speak to anyone. I was ironing all day.
Frank. Charlie Denton called me at the office. I was right in the middle of taking an order from Martin Brothers for three A-81 tractors.
Clarice. Three? Frank, that's wonderful!
Frank. Not bad. Anyway, I made Mr. Martin wait while I spoke to Charlie. Charlie says it's gonna be one hundred percent. Every family on the block. He just called to tell me that.
Clarice. Well, that's good. Everyone should be in on this.
Frank (eating). Clarry, I'm telling you this is going to be a job well done. It's how you have to do these things. Everybody getting together first . . . and boom, it's over. I can't wait till it's started. It's been long enough.
Clarice. I saw her out the window today, hanging clothes in her yard like nothing was wrong. She didn't even look this way.
Frank. What time is it?
Clarice. Now you just asked me two minutes ago. It's about three minutes to seven. What's the matter with you? You'll be getting yourself an ulcer over this thing. Relax, Frank. Here, have some more pie.
Frank. No. No more.
[He gets up and walks around nervously, slapping his fist into his palm. Roger is looking at him now. He is tense, excited, completely caught up in the impending event.]
Frank. This is something big, you know that, Clarry? Can't hurt anyone's feelings. Every time you turn around you're hurting some idiot's feelings. Well that's tough, I say . . .
Clarice (indicating Roger). Frank . . .
Frank. He can hear! He's old enough. You want something bad, you gotta go out and get it! That's how this world is. Boy, I like this, Clarry. You know what it makes me feel like? It makes me feel like a man!
[He stalks up and down the room for a few moments as they watch him. Then he goes to the window and stands there looking out.]
Clarice (quietly). I think I'll just stack the dishes.
[She starts to do it. The doorbell rings. Roger jumps up.]
Roger. I'll get it.
[He goes to the door and opens it. Arthur Hayes stands there a bit apologetically. He wears no overcoat, having just come from next door. He looks extremely upset.]
Arthur. Rog, is your dad in?
Roger. Sure. Come on in, Mr. Hayes.
[Arthur walks in slowly. Frank turns around, still excited. He goes over to Arthur.]
Frank (loud). Hey, Artie. Come on in.
Arthur. Hello, Frank . . .
Frank (laughing). What can I do for you? (Arthur looks hesitatingly at Roger.) Oh, sure. Rog, go help your mother.
Roger (annoyed). Okay . . .
[He walks off to dining table.]
Frank (chuckling). That's some kid, isn't he, Artie? How old is yours now?
Arthur. Twenty-one months.
Frank. Yeah. Well, that's still nothing but a crying machine. Wait a couple years. He'll kill you.
Arthur. I guess so.
Frank. And how! Sit down for a minute, Artie. What's on your mind?
Arthur (sitting. Hesitantly). Well, I don't know . . . I just . . . well . . . I just wanted . . . to talk.
Frank. No kidding. Say, y'know you look a little green around the gills? What's the matter?
[Arthur Hayes takes off his eyeglasses and begins to polish them, a nervous habit in which he indulges when upset.]
Arthur. Nothing. I've had an upset stomach for a couple of days. Maybe that's it.
Frank (nodding). Yeah, that'll get you down all right. Probably a virus.
[Arthur nods and they look at each other awkwardly for a moment.]
Frank. Well, what did you want to talk to me about?
[Arthur looks at the floor, trying to frame his answer carefully, afraid to offend. Finally he blurts it out.]
Arthur. What do you think about this thing tonight?
Frank (surprised). What do you mean what do I think about it?
Arthur. Well, I've been kind of going over it all day, Frank. I talked with Phyllis before.
Frank (a little hard). And . . .
Arthur. Well, it was just talk. We were just talking it over to get clear on it, you know.
Frank. Go ahead.
Arthur. And . . . well, look, Frank, it's a pretty hard thing. Supposing it were you?
Frank. It's not.
Arthur. Well, I know that, but supposing it were?
[Frank stands up and goes over to Arthur.]
Frank. Your glasses are clean. You wear 'em out, you have to buy a new pair. (Arthur looks down at his glasses, then puts them on nervously.) Now what about it, Artie? What if I was the guy?
Arthur. Well, you know . . . how would you feel?
Frank. How would I feel, huh? Now that's a good question, Artie. I'll answer it for you. It doesn't make any difference how I'd feel. Now let me ask you a question. Is he a lifelong buddy of yours?
Arthur. Well, now, you know he's not, Frank.
Frank. Do you know him to say hello to?
Arthur. That's not the idea. He's-
Frank. Artie . . . you don't even know the guy. What are you getting yourself all hot and bothered about? We all agreed, didn't we?
Arthur. Yes . . . everybody agreed.
Frank. You. Me. The Dentons. The McAllisters. The Fredericks. The Schofields. Every family on Sycamore Street for that matter. We all agreed. That's how it is. The majority. Right?
Arthur. Well . . . I think we all ought to talk it over, maybe. Let it wait a few days.
[He takes off his glasses again and begins to wipe them.]
Frank. Artie . . . we talked it over. (Frank takes the handkerchief out of Arthur's hand and tucks it into his pocket.) In about ten minutes we're starting. We expect to have a solid front, you know what I mean? Everybody. You included. You're my next-door neighbor, boy. I don't want to hear people saying Artie Hayes wasn't there.
Arthur (hesitantly). Well, I don't know, Frank. I thought-
[The phone rings. Frank goes toward it.]
Frank. Go home, Artie. Don't worry about it. I'll see you in a few minutes. (Frank goes to the phone and picks it up. Arthur stares at him.) Hello . . . (Arthur turns away and walks slowly to door.) Speaking.
[Arthur goes out, dazed and frightened. Clarice comes into living room and stands waiting as Frank listens to phone.]
Frank (angry). What do you mean you can't get here? (Pause) Well, this is a great time to call! (Pause) I know. Yeah. (He slams the phone down. To Clarice.) Our sitter can't get here. How d'you like that?
Clarice. What's wrong with her?
Frank. I don't know. She's got a cold, or something. Nice dependable girl you pick.
Clarice (snapping). Well, I didn't exactly arrange for her to get a cold, you know.
Frank. Look, Clarry, we're going to this thing no matter what.
Clarice. Well, I'm not leaving Chris with Roger. They'll claw each other to pieces.
Frank. Then we'll take them with us.
Clarice. You wouldn't . . .
Frank. Who wouldn't? We're doing it for them as much as anyone else, aren't we? Well, they might as well see it.
Clarice. Maybe I'd better stay home with them.
Frank. No, sir. You've been in on this from the beginning. You're going. Come on, get Chris dressed. We haven't got much time.
Clarice. Well . . . whatever you think, Frank . . .
Frank. I'm telling you it's all right. Won't hurt 'em a bit. (To Roger) What d'you say, son? Want to come along?
Roger (eagerly). Oh, boy! Really? (Frank nods and grins. Roger leaps happily.) Gee, Dad, you're the greatest guy in all the whole world. [He runs over and hugs Frank.]
- English 1 - Damon, Saturday, February 5, 2011 at 4:51pm
The neighbors have decided, Frank particularly that they do not like a new neighboring family. The reason is not stated, perhaps different race or religion or shoe style or whatever.
Frank has evidently gotten them together to confront the neighbor, perhaps to tell them to leave?
Arthur is having second thoughts. So is the baby sitter we suspect, or at least her family. Frank's wife Clarice would also prefer not to participate.
One wonders if Frank and his so far innocent son will be the only ones to do whatever this nasty deed is.
- English 1 - Ms. Sue, Saturday, February 5, 2011 at 5:00pm
Since the author doesn't say what the conflict is about, we can use our imaginations.
Frank is obviously nervous and snaps at Roger. My guess is that Frank wants the neighborhood to confront and maybe use force on one of the neighbors for something he supposedly had done.
You need to go back through the story/play and find the specific words Frank and Roger say that show the conflict.
- English 1 - Writeacher, Saturday, February 5, 2011 at 5:07pm
The conflict between Arthur and Frank seems to be about an upcoming confrontation that the whole neighborhood is going to have with one neighbor. Perhaps they want that neighbor to move out or something, but it's clear that Frank believes all the others are united with him in whatever they intend to confront the neighbor about.
Arthur seems to represent the second thoughts that some of the "united" neighbors have had, and Frank seems to represent the idea that once a person commits to something he/she cannot change his/her mind.
So ... there's a new family on the street. According to Frank, all the other neighbors have decided to tell that new family something, and clearly it's because they don't like something about them. What kinds of things do you think neighbors would object to?
- English 1 - chelsea salam, Saturday, February 5, 2011 at 5:50pm
I don't understand how to answer the question! PLease help!
- English 1 - Ms. Sue, Saturday, February 5, 2011 at 5:54pm
Study our answers carefully.
Then, remember your directions:
Write a paragraph speculating about what you think is the underlying but unstated conflict in Thunder on Sycamore Street.
Support your ideas with details from the excerpt.
- English 1 - Damon, Saturday, February 5, 2011 at 5:55pm
I think we have answered it for you. Frank wants to confront the new family about something and has gotten the other neighbors to agree with him. The others are doubting their deal to back Frank. Arthur is the first to back out, but others will follow, including his wife and the baby sitter.
- English 1 - bob, Thursday, June 28, 2012 at 6:20pm
do your own work
- English 1 - bob, Thursday, June 28, 2012 at 6:23pm
- English 11H - rae, Friday, May 10, 2013 at 8:33am
do it yourself
Answer This Question
More Related Questions
- LA - What do you learn from the dialogue between Mr. Frank and Miep at the ...
- Lang. Arts Help - What do you learn from the dialogue between Mr. Frank and Miep...
- Life orientation - 1.distinguish between interpersonal and intrapersonal ...
- English - Please help quickly!! - I need help with making a thesis statement for...
- English Help Please - Which line of dialogue by Mr. Dussel in The Diary of Anne ...
- L.A - Read the opening line of dialogue from Anne Frank and Me: "Right now we ...
- English (The Diary of Anne Frank) - I loved this book but my homework askes me a...
- English - I am currently writing an argumentative essay about religion. The ...
- Question abt Conflict - One more question. Cause the conflict was about the land...
- Writing - i need a idea about a story novel, it has to have the following ...