Do i need a comma?
Do you still have relatives living there Kate?
Yes -- where will you put it?
Would it be
Do you still have relatives living there, Kate?
Right.
Yes, you need a comma in this sentence. The comma is necessary to separate the person's name from the question being asked. In this case, the name "Kate" acts as an appositive, which provides additional information about the person being addressed.
To determine whether a comma is needed, you can follow these steps:
1. Identify the parts of the sentence: "Do you still have relatives living there Kate?"
- Subject: "you"
- Verb: "do have"
- Direct Object: "relatives"
- Adjective Phrase: "living there"
- Appositive: "Kate"
2. Determine if the appositive is essential or nonessential:
- If the appositive is nonessential, meaning it can be removed from the sentence without changing its overall meaning or clarity, it should be set off with commas.
- If the appositive is essential, meaning it is necessary to identify or specify the noun it modifies, it does not require commas.
3. Analyze the sentence and consider the role of the appositive:
- In this sentence, the appositive "Kate" provides crucial information about who the question is directed towards, making it an essential appositive.
Based on the analysis, since "Kate" is an essential appositive, you do not need to set it off with commas in this sentence.