Wal-Mart is the largest corporation in the world, and it has obviously enjoyed tremendous success. But while many welcome its location in their communities, others do not. Some complain that its presence has too many negative effects on a community, ranging from traffic congestion to anti-union sentiment to unfair competition.
Suppose Wal-Mart has announced plans to seek approval from the planning commission of a small town to build a new store. Develop a list of the main arguments, pro and con, that could be presented at a public hearing on the matter by members of each of these groups:
1. Owners of small businesses located nearby.
2. Town residents and residents of nearby towns.
How might a Wal-Mart representative respond to the negative criticisms that might be brought up, and what other benefits could the representative offer the planning board to bolster Wal-Mart's case for gaining the board's approval?
We'll be glad to comment on your answers.
Well being that I am opposed to Wal_mart, I see no way the Wal-Mart representative can respond positviely to the negative criticisms that might be brought up, and cannot see any other benefits the representative could offer the planning board to bolster Wal-Mart's case for gaining the board's approval.
I live in a medium sized city in southern Michigan -- with three Wal-Marts within 10 miles of me. I never shop there, but all three stores seem to be doing a great business, despite stiff competition from Meijers, a Michigan-based chain with similar merchandise and pricing.
Wal-Mart reps might respond that the store serves a need in the community. You can check, but I believe it has improved some of its employee relations.
1. owners of small businesses located nearby. 2. town residents, and residents of nearby towns. How might a wal-mart representative respond to the negative criticisms that might be brought up, and what other benefits could the representative offer the planning board to bolster wal mart's case for gaining the board's approval?
1. Owners of small businesses located nearby:
Pros:
- Increased competition can lead to lower prices, benefiting consumers.
- New job opportunities may be created by Wal-Mart's presence.
- Additional foot traffic generated by Wal-Mart could benefit other nearby businesses.
- Increased tax revenue for the town as a result of Wal-Mart's operations.
Cons:
- Small businesses may struggle to compete with Wal-Mart's low prices and wide variety of products.
- Potential loss of customers to Wal-Mart, leading to reduced sales and possible business closures.
- Concerns about unfair competition and monopolistic practices.
- Fear of job losses if small businesses are unable to compete.
Wal-Mart representative response:
- Emphasize the potential benefits of competition, which can ultimately lower prices and provide more choices for consumers.
- Highlight the job creation opportunities offered by Wal-Mart, both during construction and once the store is operational.
- Address concerns about unfair competition by emphasizing that Wal-Mart operates within the bounds of the law and has policies in place to ensure fair practices.
- Offer to collaborate with small businesses, such as through partnerships or local supplier programs, to support their success and enhance the overall community economy.
- Present studies or evidence showcasing the positive impact of Wal-Mart on local economies, including increased tax revenue and job growth.
Other benefits:
- Offer to invest in local community development projects, such as infrastructure improvements or support for education programs.
- Highlight Wal-Mart's commitment to corporate social responsibility, such as environmental sustainability initiatives or charitable contributions to the community.
- Mention the potential for increased convenience and access to affordable products for residents, particularly those who may not have easy access to other retailers.
2. Town residents and residents of nearby towns:
Pros:
- The convenience of having a large retailer like Wal-Mart nearby for a wide range of products.
- Potential job opportunities for local residents, including part-time or entry-level positions.
- Increased options and competitive pricing, benefiting consumers.
- Potential positive impact on the local economy, including increased tax revenue and potential infrastructure development.
Cons:
- Concerns about increased traffic congestion and strain on local infrastructure.
- Negative impact on smaller local businesses and a sense of community identity.
- Fear of job losses if existing businesses are unable to compete with Wal-Mart.
- Possible environmental concerns associated with the construction and operation of a large-scale retail store.
Wal-Mart representative response:
- Address the traffic congestion and infrastructure concerns by offering to work with local authorities to mitigate traffic impacts through measures like expanding roadways or implementing traffic management solutions.
- Emphasize the convenience and affordability that Wal-Mart can offer to local residents, particularly those who may have limited options or face higher prices.
- Highlight the potential job opportunities that will be available to local residents, including both full-time and part-time positions.
- Address the concerns about impact on local businesses by demonstrating a commitment to supporting small businesses and offering potential partnerships or initiatives to ensure their success.
- Mention any environmental sustainability initiatives or commitments that Wal-Mart has implemented to address potential environmental concerns.
Other benefits:
- Offer to support local community initiatives or programs through initiatives like community grants, sponsorships, or volunteering efforts.
- Present examples of positive contributions made by Wal-Mart in other communities, such as support for schools, community events, or disaster relief efforts.
- Highlight the potential for improved access to a diverse range of products, particularly for residents who may need affordability or specialized options not readily available locally.