Consider the following scenario: You are aware of a problem that is costing your company productivity. This problem is caused by a fellow employee who refuses to use current technology. This employee has asked you to keep the situation to yourself, since he is one year from retirement and does not want to lose his job or have to endure new training. This employee is also very popular with everyone at the company. You have just been asked by your superiors why you think your division is not as productive as it could be. How does this employee's popularity impact your decision?
I thought that Bobpursley and I covered this topic pretty well yesterday.
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1289858844
In this scenario, the employee's popularity can certainly impact your decision on how to handle the situation. Here's an explanation of the different factors to consider:
1. Potential impact on relationships: If the employee is popular, it suggests that they have a good rapport with others in the company. Taking action against them might strain your relationship with not only the employee in question but also with other colleagues who support them. You'll need to evaluate the potential consequences of your actions on workplace dynamics and interpersonal relationships.
2. Prioritizing productivity and organizational goals: As an employee, it is essential to prioritize the productivity and goals of the organization. If this individual's refusal to adopt current technology is indeed causing a significant loss in productivity, it is crucial to weigh the long-term consequences for the company against the potential impact on relationships. The focus should be on finding a solution that benefits the company as a whole.
3. Ethical considerations: You should consider the ethical implications of keeping the employee's request for secrecy in mind. While it's important to respect confidentiality, it is also essential to uphold honesty and integrity in your professional responsibilities. Assess whether revealing this information aligns with your ethical values and professional obligations.
In order to make a decision in such a scenario, it is recommended to follow these steps:
1. Gather evidence: Collect data or evidence that objectively supports your claim that the employee's resistance to using current technology is hampering productivity. This may include performance metrics or feedback from other team members or stakeholders.
2. Assess impact: Evaluate the extent of the impact the employee's behavior is having on the division's productivity and the overall success of the organization. Consider the financial implications, the effect on team morale, and the potential benefits that could be gained by addressing the issue.
3. Analyze potential solutions: Identify potential solutions that balance the organization's goals with the employee's concerns. Consider options such as offering training, providing assistance, or finding compromises that can help the employee adapt to new technology without undue stress.
4. Discuss the issue: Engage in a conversation with your superiors to discuss your observations and concerns about the division's productivity. Present the evidence you have gathered and provide suggestions for improvement. Be transparent about the employee's request for confidentiality, but express your commitment to finding a resolution that benefits the company.
In summary, the employee's popularity does impact your decision, but it should not overshadow your responsibility to address a problem that hinders productivity. By carefully considering the evidence, weighing the impact on relationships, prioritizing organizational goals, and addressing ethical considerations, you can make a well-informed decision about how to handle the situation.