My assignment states: Find at least two instances of conflicts between the legal and ethical issues confronting the education of ELL's. For example, some states have ceased funding for bilingual education and may not instruct the ELL's in their native languages. However the issue still remains that schools are responsible for instructing ELL's and those students have to learn English in order to succeed in school. How do schools meet the needs of the ELL's without breaking state law?

*I am not understanding what I am suppose to do. Do I find an ethical issue then a legal issue, for example a court case?

The assignment asks you to find two examples of CONFLICT between ethical and legal issues. The example given shows one instance of a conflict between legal and ethical issues.

So it would be like: legally they are not funding for the teachers to teach in the native languages and ethically they still have to teach those students?

My assignment states: Find at least two instances of conflicts between the legal and ethical issues confronting the education of ELL's. For example, some states have ceased funding for bilingual education and may not instruct the ELL's in their native languages. However the issue still remains that schools are responsible for instructing ELL's and those students have to learn English in order to succeed in school. How do schools meet the needs of the ELL's without breaking state law?

To fulfill your assignment, you can indeed identify both legal and ethical issues related to the education of English Language Learners (ELLs). Below, I will guide you on how to approach this task.

1. Identify Legal Issues:
Start by examining legislation, policies, or court cases that impact the education of ELLs in your country or specific state.
- Search for laws or policies that address bilingual education or the instruction of ELLs in their native language.
- Look for any changes or funding cuts in bilingual education programs that may affect how schools serve ELLs.

Once you have identified a legal issue, you can explain how it conflicts with ethical concerns in the next step.

2. Identify Ethical Issues:
Next, identify ethical concerns related to the education of ELLs. Here are some examples:
- Equity and access: Consider the moral responsibility of providing quality education for all students, including ELLs.
- Cultural and linguistic preservation: Explore the ethical implications of maintaining and valuing students' native languages and cultures.
- Inclusive education: Examine how schools can ensure that ELLs are not excluded or marginalized in mainstream classrooms.

Once you have identified an ethical issue, explain how it conflicts with the legal issue discovered in the previous step.

3. Analyze the Conflict:
Now that you have identified both a legal and an ethical issue, analyze how they conflict. In your example, one legal issue is the funding cuts for bilingual education, which may prevent instruction in the native language of ELLs. An ethical issue could be the responsibility of schools to provide equal opportunities for ELLs to succeed academically, which may involve providing support in their native language.

4. Suggest Solutions:
To address the conflict between the legal and ethical issues, suggest potential solutions or strategies that schools can employ. For instance:
- Explore alternative instructional models that align with state laws while ensuring ELLs receive the support they need, such as ESL (English as a Second Language) programs.
- Advocate for policy changes or increased funding to support bilingual education programs, emphasizing the benefits to both ELLs and the broader community.
- Collaborate with community organizations and families to enhance cultural and linguistic support outside of the school setting.

Remember to gather evidence and examples to support your analysis and suggestions. Additionally, consult relevant academic literature, reputable sources, and your instructor for further guidance and clarification on your assignment requirements.