Monday

October 20, 2014

October 20, 2014

Posted by **Anonymous** on Monday, March 8, 2010 at 11:45am.

a. Investment X should be selected

b. Investment Y should be selected

c. Investment X and Y provide the same payback period

d. Neither investment is acceptable under the payback method

- Finance Management -
**Sandi**, Saturday, April 2, 2011 at 9:11amInvestment X:

You need $200 more to recoup your initial investment of $4000, which you can get from the third year cash flow of $3700.

You only need the pro-rata amount, which will be $200/$3700 = 0.054 year

Pay back period for X = 2.054 years

Investment Y:

You need only $2700 from second year to recoup your initial investment of $4000.

You only need the pro-rata amount, which will be $2700/$2800 = 0.964 year

Pay back period for Y = 1.964 years

Investment Y is a better choice based on payback method alone

Payback period is the amount of time required for an investment to generate cash flows to recoup its initial investment.

An investment is acceptable if its calculated payback is less than prescribed number of years for the said company.

Payback period suffer from some of the following disadvantages:

It ignore the time value of money

It determines to accept or reject projects on an ad hoc basis.

It ignore the cash flow beyond the cut-off period

Its biased against an long term project as compared to a short term.

Other methods such as NPV and IRR take into consideration the time value of money and risk involved in the project by discounting future cash flows.

**Answer this Question**

**Related Questions**

Finance - Assume a $4,000 investment and the following cash flows for two ...

finance - What is the payback period of the following project? Initial ...

Managerial finance - Superior Manufacturing is lauching a new product, that is ...

Math - 2. Your firm is considering two projects: Project A and Project B with ...

Math - A manufacturing firm is thinking of launching a new product. The firm ...

Financial Management (Math) - 2. Your firm is considering two projects: Project ...

Business finance - Question No 1: Sumi Inc. has policy of paying a Rs. 9 per ...

Financial Analysis - Reposting generically: How does a huge investment in cash ...

Math - You have available five different investment strategies and their ...

Statistics - You have available five different investment strategies and their ...