The Progressive Movement has been characterized as a movement that brought a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene between 1890 and 1917. Other historians say that although well-intentioned, in the end they failed to achieve their goals. Your task is to study this question and decide on which side of this question you agree with.
Your discussion should include the following:
The two sides of the debate are "The Progressive Movement brought a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene" or "The Progressive Movement was unsuccessful in its attempt to bring about a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene." Based on which side you are supporting:
1. From the following list of stakeholders, choose the ones that would be on your side of the debate and state why.
Susan B. Anthony
Elizabeth Cady Stanton
Alice Stone Blackwell
Upton Sinclair
Ida Tarbell
Jane Addams
Teddy Roosevelt
Benjamin Harrison
Grover Cleveland
Andrew Carnegie
Joseph Lincoln Steffens
Horatio Alger
Booker T. Washington
W.E.B. DuBois
2. Choose one person from above and discuss the following:
What were the programs he/she supported?
Was this a unified movement with one agenda?
What were their successes?
What were their failures?
I agree with the Progressive movement. But I have no idea what to do now. Or who alot of these people are.
Enter each of the names you listed until you find information that helps you understand them.
http://www.answers.com
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page
With all Wikipedia search results, be sure to check out all the external links and further references at the bottom of each Wikipedia page.
http://www.google.com
The Progressive Movement has been characterized as a movement that brought a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene between 1890 and 1917. Other historians say that although well-intentioned, in the end they failed to achieve their goals. Your task is to study this question and decide on which side of this question you agree with.
Your discussion should include the following:
The two sides of the debate are "The Progressive Movement brought a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene" or "The Progressive Movement was unsuccessful in its attempt to bring about a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene." Based on which side you are supporting:
1. From the following list of stakeholders, choose the ones that would be on your side of the debate and state why.
To approach this question, let's start by discussing the two sides of the debate concerning the Progressive Movement's impact on American politics between 1890 and 1917.
The first perspective argues that the Progressive Movement brought a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene. Supporters of this view contend that progressive reforms during this period aimed to address social, economic, and political injustices. They pushed for reforms such as women's suffrage, anti-trust regulation, worker protections, and political reforms to fight corruption. Advocates of this perspective argue that the movement's dedication to social justice and equitable policies brought about positive changes to the American political landscape.
The second perspective argues that the Progressive Movement was unsuccessful in its attempt to bring about a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene. Critics of the movement claim that, despite their good intentions, the progressives fell short of achieving their goals. They argue that many of the proposed reforms were compromised or watered down, leading to limited progress in terms of social equality and political ethics.
Now let's discuss some of the key stakeholders involved and their positions within the debate:
1. Susan B. Anthony, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Alice Stone Blackwell: These figures were prominent women's suffrage activists. They strongly supported the progressive cause and fought for women's rights, including the right to vote. They would likely be on the side arguing that the Progressive Movement brought a sense of justice and morality.
2. Upton Sinclair, Ida Tarbell, Jane Addams, Joseph Lincoln Steffens: These individuals were investigative journalists and social reformers. They focused on exposing corruption, inequality, and social problems. They would most likely align with the perspective that the Progressive Movement brought justice and morality.
3. Teddy Roosevelt: As the 26th president of the United States, Roosevelt was a significant progressive leader. He advocated for political and economic reforms, such as trust-busting and conservation efforts. Roosevelt would be on the side arguing that the Progressive Movement brought justice and morality.
4. Benjamin Harrison, Grover Cleveland, Andrew Carnegie: These individuals represent political leaders and business figures of the time. While their positions might have been more nuanced, they may have supported certain progressive policies while opposing others. Their stance would depend on the specific movements and reforms being discussed.
5. Horatio Alger: Alger was a popular author associated with the "rags to riches" narrative, which focused on individual success through hard work and determination. His perspective might lean more toward the argument that individual efforts, rather than collective reforms, were responsible for achieving justice and morality.
6. Booker T. Washington, W.E.B. DuBois: These were prominent African American leaders. While they may have differing opinions on the effectiveness of progressive reforms, both Washington and DuBois advocated for racial equality and social progress. They were critical figures within the Progressive Movement.
Now, let's choose one person from the list and discuss their perspective, programs they supported, whether the movement had a unified agenda, and their successes and failures.
Let's take Jane Addams as an example:
Jane Addams was a renowned social reformer and a key figure in the Progressive Movement. She is best known as the founder of Hull House, a settlement house in Chicago that aimed to alleviate poverty and improve social conditions. Addams believed in the importance of social cooperation and community efforts to solve societal issues. She supported a wide range of programs, including public health initiatives, education, and social work reforms.
The Progressive Movement was not a unified movement with a single agenda. It encompassed various groups and organizations that fought for different causes while sharing a common goal of addressing social injustices. Some progressives focused on labor rights, others on political reforms, and yet others on women's suffrage, among other issues.
Jane Addams achieved notable successes in her efforts. Hull House became a successful model for providing social services and community support. Additionally, Addams was an influential advocate for the inclusion of women's voices in politics and society. She co-founded the Women's International League for Peace and Freedom, advocating for peace and women's rights across the world.
However, the Progressive Movement also faced significant failures. Some progressive reforms faced strong opposition from vested interests, resulting in compromised or weakened legislation. For example, while the movement made progress in areas such as workers' rights and women's suffrage, it couldn't completely eliminate social and economic disparities. Racial inequality continued to persist, and many of the reforms fell short of achieving their intended scope and impact.
Overall, while the Progressive Movement made significant strides in improving social and political conditions, the ultimate success of their endeavors is a matter of interpretation and analysis. The debate over the movement's achievements and shortcomings has continued among historians and scholars. As the question prompts you to take a side, you can now elaborate on why you support the argument that the Progressive Movement brought a sense of justice and morality to the American political scene. Feel free to utilize the information provided to construct your response.