Posted by mysterychicken on Saturday, February 20, 2010 at 5:04pm.
41. A group calling itself "Virus Alive!" believes that viruses are living organisms. They have petitioned the scientific community to include viruses in the biological classification system. You are a scientist assigned to explain to this group that, although they share many characteristics of living organisms, viruses are NOT alive. You are instructed to be considerate of the group's position and discuss the characteristics of living organisims that are similar to the characteristics of viruses. However, you must then make the case that these similarities do not make a virus a living organism. Write your speech to "Virus Alive!" in two to three well-developed paragraphs.
The characteristics of living organisms are: movement, respiration, sensitivity, growth, reproduction, excretion and nutrition. Viruses such as HIV are clearly capable of movement within the blood stream. Cancer provides a great example of how a virus can reproduce within a host. Viruses grow by within the host's cells, where they gain their nutrition and consequently excrete. Virus sensitivity refers to how resistant viruses are to drugs or treatements, or alternatively put how likely they are to be destroyed by treatement. As such viruses appear to possess all the characteristics of living beings.
However, Viruses do not have a cellular structure, and can only exist for any considerable period of time within a host. Viruses do not have their own metabolism, for which again they are dependent upon a host, and they need a host cell to make new products, so they can't reproduce outside a host cell. When reproduction is specified as a characteristic of life we refer to cell division. Given a viruses inability to perform several characteristics of life independently of a host I conclude that a virus is not a living organism.
- Biology - bobpursley, Saturday, February 20, 2010 at 5:16pm
It is fine,however....
Your argument is based on your premise and definition of the characteristics of living organisms. Not all will agree with those.
Take humans for example: Is a man not a living thing because he himself cannot reproduce...it takes a host female.
Is a man not a living thing because he cannot digest food without bacteria flora in his intestine?
I am nitpicking, but you ought to realize ones conclusions are oft dependent on ones premises.
Consider the invasion of Iraq: Was it a good thing, or bad thing. Well, it depends on the premises, and perhaps some crystal ball predictions on each alternative.
So in your short paragraph, you did answer the prompt, but in real life, one has to critically examine ones own beliefs when doing analysis. Often, we ourselves get in the way of our own thinking.
- Biology - mysterychicken, Saturday, February 20, 2010 at 5:17pm
I'm gonna change my words up a bit because of what you said; Thanks!
- Biology - Ms. Sue, Saturday, February 20, 2010 at 5:20pm
Your argument is not compelling and I'm not convinced.
Tell me WHY a virus isn't living. This isn't the place to waffle!
Answer This Question
More Related Questions
- Biology - 41. A group calling itself "Virus Alive!" believes that viruses are ...
- AP Stats - Viruses are infectious agents that often cause diseases in plants. ...
- AP Statistics - Viruses are infectious agents that often cause diseases in ...
- biology - please help me with these to questions! The trait that viruses share ...
- Computer Viruses - A virus that infects an application program is known as a ...
- Biology - 26. The relationship between population growth and resources can be ...
- 10th grade - what characteristics of life do viruses have?describe the ways in ...
- Biology - Some viruses cause the host cell to reproduce both itself and the ...
- Biology - Why are RNA viruses much more deadly than DNAbased viruses
- biology - do biologists believe that viruses are alive