What risks are inherent in closing a story like Separating with a question such as "Why?" Can a story about a middle-class suburban family bear the weight of a question like that? What does the young boy mean by that question--and what does his father hear in it?

I don't know what the significane of Why is...the whole story confuses me so much

Unfortunately, I am unfamiliar with the story.

However, the question of "why?" something is done might make one more aware of the assets and liabilities of the actions along with other options that might be taken in reaching desired goals.

Rather than just reacting, answering "why?" gets you to think about the proposed actions. Even if the actions have already been taken, knowing why might help in considering similar actions for future situations.

I hope this helps.

In order to understand the significance of the closing question "Why?" in the story "Separating" and its impact on a middle-class suburban family, we need to analyze the story and its characters. Let's break it down step by step:

1. Read and analyze the story: Begin by carefully reading and analyzing the story. Take note of the main characters, their relationships, and the events that transpire. Pay particular attention to the relationships between the young boy and his father, as well as the overall theme and tone of the story.

2. Identify the context: Understanding the context of the story is crucial to interpreting its meaning. Consider the setting, time period, and social dynamics at play. This will help you grasp the underlying tensions and conflicts within the family.

3. Examine the young boy's question: When the young boy asks "Why?" at the end of the story, it signifies a turning point. This question could be interpreted in various ways, depending on the context you've identified. It could be a genuine inquiry about the reasons behind the family's separation, a plea for reassurance, or a reflection of the boy's confusion and emotional turmoil.

4. Explore the father's response: The father's interpretation of the question can also have different meanings. It could represent his realization of the profound impact the separation has on his child, or it could reflect his own struggles in finding a satisfactory answer. The father might perceive the question as a challenge to his decision-making or as a cry for understanding.

5. Analyze the risks and implications: Closing a story like "Separating" with a question like "Why?" presents inherent risks. By leaving the ending open-ended, the author invites readers to reflect on the complexities and consequences of the family's situation. This approach can create ambiguity and provoke thought, but it might also leave readers feeling frustrated or unsatisfied if they desire a clear resolution to the story.

6. Consider the story's suitability: Whether a story about a middle-class suburban family can bear the weight of such a question depends on the narrative's depth and complexity. If the story has been carefully developed, with well-rounded characters and thought-provoking themes, then the use of the question "Why?" as a closing moment can resonate powerfully with readers. However, if the story lacks sufficient depth or fails to provide adequate context, the closing question might feel unwarranted or confusing.

To fully grasp the significance of the closing question in "Separating," it's essential to engage in a thorough analysis of the story and its characters. By immersing yourself in the narrative and contemplating the possible meanings and interpretations, you can begin to unravel the confusion and gain a deeper understanding of the story's intent.