Posted by mysterychicken on Saturday, November 7, 2009 at 3:58pm.
I had to write an essay analyzing a short story. I chose The Birds by Daphne du Maurier and this is what I got:
Daphne du Maurier’s short story The Birds is a story of an old war veteran, his family, and how they battle fierce birds. It starts out on the third of December on the Cornish coast of England. The weather has changed overnight from a mild autumn to a cold, harsh winter. Nat Hocken, who works at a farm to support his family, notices a lot of birds that appear more restless than usual. Nobody else believes Nat’s theories about what the birds might be up to until they start attacking. Soon, it is too dangerous to be outside as the birds have already killed all the people around Nat and his family. He boards up his house and eventually they are safe.
The Birds was written by du Maurier to tell us about how humans think that they are the most intelligent race in the world but by the end of the story we realize just how small and useless we actually are against nature. Though du Maurier did show how the birds almost wiped out humans, I think her plot was not believable and realistic, thus making the story not interesting to read.
Even though in the end, we see that Nat is safely in his home, the external conflict is not fully resolved; it just ends with him sitting, smoking his last cigarette. I did not like this because it doesn’t tell us the outcome of the birds’ attack: Do they eventually leave or take over the world?
Du Maurier uses small details that visually describe the birds and make the images vivid in our minds. ‘Little brains…stabbing beaks…piercing eyes…’ but she doesn’t exactly explain where they came from, and why.
In conclusion, The Birds was a lengthy short story about how humans tried to survive fierce bird attacks that were highly unrealistic. The readers can’t connect with the characters at all since no one shares these experiences, and since it’s not that easy to understand, I wouldn’t recommend it to most children.
Is this OK?
Literature - GuruBlue, Saturday, November 7, 2009 at 4:05pm
There is a lot of repetition in this. Example:You said that du Maurier wrote the story three times.
Next...The story is about man's eternal conflict with nature. Writers have been taking on this issue for centuries because man has been trying to resolve that issue.Yes, man has an ego problem and that is part of the "problem". I don't think that you thought through what the author was trying to say. I am not a du Maurier enthusiast, but she is a valid author. You need to organize your throughts before you sit down to write.
Literature - bobpursley, Saturday, November 7, 2009 at 4:09pm
I agree, MC. The story was about the conflict with nature that man often takes for granted. The repetition is a bit tiring. I have always found in an analysis repetition to be a bit insulting to the reader. I get the impression you are trying to meet some artificial word length.
Work on the repetition, and your thoughts about how the author presented the conflict with nature. Who won?
Literature - mysterychicken, Saturday, November 7, 2009 at 4:25pm
OK, I'll work on it. Also, I didn't realize i was repeating..
Answer This Question
More Related Questions
- Literature - [This activity is from Daphne Du Maurier's short story, The Birds] ...
- Literature - I had to write an essay analyzing a short story. I wrote about The ...
- ENGLISH - Do you know the story about "The Old Man" by Daphne du Maurier? I've ...
- Writing--Can someone please help me with this? - Write a description of a scene ...
- Writing (Writeacher and Ms. Sue) - Write a description of a scene in the story "...
- Literature - In "The Birds", ((Short story by Daphne du Maurier))what is the ...
- Literature - In "The Birds" by Daphne Du Maurier, what important news is ...
- Literature - 'Du Maurier, who wrote the short story The Birds, tells us that the...
- english - the characters nat hocken from the story "the birds by,Daphne du ...
- Literature - I have to write an essay describing the external conflict Nat ...