Posted by **John** on Monday, July 6, 2009 at 5:48am.

1. It's your problem, not my problem.

2. It's your problem, and it's not my problem.

3. It's your problem, but it's not my problem.

(What does #1 mean? Does #1 mean #2 or #3? Or do you have another expression which is the full form of #1?)

4. I think the girl (to be) her.

5. I think the girl (to be) she.

(Which one is correct?)

- English -
**Writeacher**, Monday, July 6, 2009 at 8:05am
#1 means that "you" need to take care of the problem, not "me." In other words, whoever the speaker is doesn't feel responsible for whatever the other person did!

2 and 3 are grammatically OK, but not as smooth as 1.

5 is correct -- correct phrasing is "I think the girl is she." (Out of context, it's hard to tell what it means.) You use "she" rather than "her" because any form of the verb to be, when used as a main verb of a clause, requires a pronoun after it to be in the same case as a subject. Think of the verb "to be" as an equals mark in math. Here are some examples:

My brother is a retired mechanic.

My brother = a retired mechanic.

The cat is a ginger tabby.

The cat = a ginger tabby.

(Is Mrs. Smith there?) This is she.

(Is Mrs. Smith there?) This = she.

http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/verbs.htm#linking

## Answer This Question

## Related Questions

- English - 1. The hospital is for certain people. 2. He has a certain problem. 3...
- Algebra - Use the above graph of f(x) to complete the following table for ...
- math,help - can someone help me with this i am lost now i've been doing math for...
- Algenra - How do I work this problem, it is not a homework problem but a problem...
- Algebra - How do I work this problem, it is not a homework problem but a problem...
- math - What strategy did you use in solving this problem? 22. Suppose that you ...
- More Math 2 See If You Can Help Me... :) - Problem: a^2-9 a^2-3a...
- Management Accounting - well i try to solve this problem but it look so ...
- trig - I'm trying to see if the teacher didn't give us the right problem or if I...
- Calculus - Given two problems: Problem A: Tau = Integral(0 to v) v/(q^2 - v^2) ...

More Related Questions