why does a soluble impurity reduce the melting point range of a pure compound ?

why is it advisable to run a mixed melting point determination on samples of two different compositions before concluding that the two compounds are identical ?

In general, a tighter packed crystal lattice of a solid will have a higher melting point. Impurities tend to disrupt the crystal lattice, so they always lower the melting point to a certain limit, which is called the eutectic point. The blend is called a eutectic mixture.

When two substances have similar or identical melting points individually, and the mixture has a substantially lower melting point, we conclude that one substance acts as an impurity of the other, hence the lower melting point. This test (melting point of the mixture) serves to confirm if two substances are identical.

An excellent PowerPoint presentation answers both of your question in a clear and concise way can be found in the following link. Microsoft Powerpoint is required to view the presentation which needs to be downloaded.

faculty.swosu.edu*william.kelly*mp_pl.ppt

(replace each of the two * with a /)

#1. But what about reducing the melting point RANGE?

#2. But why TWO different compositions? Why won't one work just as well?

A soluble impurity reduces the melting point range of a pure compound due to the following reasons:

1. Eutectic Point: When a pure compound is mixed with a soluble impurity, it forms a eutectic mixture, which has a lower melting point than the pure compound. The impurity disrupts the regular arrangement of molecules in the crystal lattice, making it easier for the compound to overcome the intermolecular forces and melt at a lower temperature.

2. Intermolecular Interactions: The presence of the soluble impurity can weaken the intermolecular interactions (such as hydrogen bonding or van der Waals forces) between the molecules of the pure compound. This decreases the energy required to break these interactions, leading to a lower melting point.

Concerning the mixed melting point determination, it is advisable to perform this experiment on samples of two different compositions before concluding that the compounds are identical due to the following reasons:

1. Impurities: The mixed melting point determination is used to check the similarity of two compounds based on their melting point ranges. However, if both compounds contain impurities, the impurities can affect the melting point, making it difficult to determine the identity of the compounds based on this test alone.

2. Identification of Solid Mixtures: Running the mixed melting point determination on samples of two different compositions helps to determine whether the compounds are identical or if they form a eutectic mixture. If the compounds have the same melting point range and form a eutectic mixture, they are likely different compounds with distinct melting points.

By comparing the mixed melting point behavior of two compounds with different compositions, it becomes more evident whether the compounds are truly identical or if impurities or eutectic mixtures are present that may affect the melting point.

A soluble impurity reduces the melting point range of a pure compound because the impurity disrupts the regular arrangement of the compound's molecules. In a pure compound, the molecules are arranged in an orderly manner, and the melting point corresponds to the temperature at which these molecules break apart and transition from a solid to a liquid state. However, when a soluble impurity is present, it can "interfere" with the molecular arrangement, effectively weakening the forces that hold the compound together. As a result, the impure compound may melt at a lower temperature and over a wider range of temperatures compared to the pure compound.

It is advisable to run a mixed melting point determination on samples of two different compositions before concluding that the two compounds are identical because it helps to establish the similarity or identity of the compounds based on their melting characteristics.

During a mixed melting point determination, a small sample of the suspected compound is mixed with a known pure compound of the same type. The mixture is then heated, and the temperature range at which the mixed sample melts is compared to the pure compound's melting point range.

If the two compounds are the same, their melting points will match or exhibit a narrow range of temperatures. This indicates that they have similar molecular structures and intermolecular forces. However, if the melting point range of the mixture is different from the melting point range of the pure compound, it suggests that the compounds are not identical and may have different compositions or impurities.

By comparing the melting points of mixed samples with known pure compounds, one can determine the similarity or identity of the compounds, ensuring accurate characterization and analysis.