Posted by Steve on Tuesday, April 14, 2009 at 1:39pm.
The equation
MnO4^- + H2O ==> MnO2 + OH^-
doesn't balance. Mn is OK. H doesn't balance and neither does O. Placing a 2 in front of H2O makes it balance.
I don't do it exactly as you did.
Here is how I do redox equations.
MnO4^- ==> MnO2 in basic soln.
a. oxidation state of Mn on left is +7 and on right is +4. So add 3 electrons to the left to balance the change in oxidation state.
MnO4^- + 3e ==> MnO2
b. Count the charges. On the left is -4 and on the right is zero.
b1. If acid solution, add H^+ to balance the charge. That doesn't apply in this case.
b2. If basic solution, add OH^- to balance the charge.
MnO4^- + 3e ==> MnO2 + 4OH^-
c. Now add water (not always needed) to balance the OH^- added.
MnO4^- + 3e + 2H2O ==>MnO2 + 4OH^-
d. check it.
Mn is ok.
6 O on left and right.
4 H on left and right.
4- charge on left and right.
Everything OK.
Some profs use this method but delete part b2 and balance everything as if all equations are acidic. When everything is balanced, they add OH^- to each H^+ and re-balance. I don't like to do that because it's two balancing steps instead of one.
Related Questions
Chemistry - I need help splitting this reaction into 1/2 reactions 3I2(s) + ...
chemistry - Balancing Redox Reaction in Basic Solution CN- + MnO-4 --> ...
Chemistry - 1. Tube # 3: (a) It started out as purple, and turned into green. (...
chem again - One more question- how do I balance this half-reaction in terms of ...
chemistry - Balance using oxidation Number Methode A. MnO4- + C2H4 + H20 --&...
Chemistry - What is the reduction half-reaction for the reaction between iron(...
Chemistry - What is the reduction half-reaction for the reaction between iron(II...
chemistry - Balance using oxidation Number Methode A. MnO4- + C2H4 + H20 --&...
Chemistry - I am having trouble with the balancing the oxidation-reduction ...
chemistry - Balance the following redox reactions assuming a basic solution. ...
For Further Reading