A few more questions on Antigone; Can someone please check my answers?:
1. When Ismene and Antigone disagree in the first scene, Ismene says "You are unwise but a loyal friend indeed to those who love you." Is it an accurate picture of Antigone? Why or why not? Explain your answer.
Ans- I think this one might be on personal opinion but I think this is an accurate picture of Antigone because she may be unwise to break the law but she is loyal to her brother whom she loved and who loves her.
2. Compare and contrast Antigone and Creon in the beginning of the play.
Ans- In the beginning of the play, Antigone is loyal to her dead brother and brave to her brother; Creon is cruel in the beginning to make such a law.
Thanks! -MC
1. sounds good.
2. Antigone, Ismene, and their brothers were all nieces/nephews to Creon. What does this say about his sense of family? Anything?
Chopsticks, your answer was not helpful. It's better to post nothing than to post unhelpful comments.
1. Your answer to the first question seems to be based on personal interpretation, which is fine. Just remember to support your answer with evidence from the text. In this case, you could refer to Antigone's decision to bury her brother against the law and argue that her loyalty to her brother outweighs her wisdom in that particular situation. You could also mention how Antigone expresses her devotion to family throughout the play, further reinforcing Ismene's statement about her loyalty.
To get a more comprehensive understanding of Antigone's character, you could analyze her actions and motivations throughout the play. Consider examining her defiance against societal norms and her belief in honoring her family's honor and traditions. Additionally, you could explore her dialogue with other characters, such as her interactions with Creon and her passionate speeches defending her actions.
2. Your answer to the second question provides a basic comparison and contrast between Antigone and Creon in the beginning of the play. However, consider delving deeper into their character traits, motivations, and beliefs to provide a more thorough analysis.
For instance, you could expand on Antigone's determination to honor her dead brother by burying him properly, highlighting her loyalty and bravery in the face of the king's decree. On the other hand, you could explore Creon's initial position as a ruler enforcing strict laws, emphasizing his adherence to state authority and his perception of Antigone's actions as a threat to his rule.
To support your answer, you could examine specific scenes or dialogue between Antigone and Creon, paying attention to their differing views on laws, authority, family, and justice. These analyses will provide a more nuanced comparison and contrast, enhancing your understanding of the characters and their roles in the play.