Why is the Old Man and the Sea such a good book? I have to do a review on it and I usually like classic books, but I didn't really like this one. Can someone please explain to me what other people like about this book? Thanks!

Although I didn't like the book either, it certainly is well-written. You may get some ideas about why it's a classic by reading about the themes that Hemingway explores.

http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/oldman/themes.html

Yeah, I read all of that. I still don't quite get the point of the book.

I have to admit, I didn't think much of it either, I considered it a minor work compared to the For Whom the Bells Toll. However, many will disagree with me.

Read Weinmeir's critism here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Old_Man_and_the_Sea

I do see the man religion elevated from the prior works to a peak here. But to me, a work should stand on its own. Again, others will disagree.

Perhaps you are female...this is most definately a man book, if you are a man into worshiping man.

Others like the realism (I didn't) Many see literary critism of Christ in Man (I didn't). Maybe someone who read and like the book will comment.

Yes, I am female. And I don't like fishing, but I do like nature.

I don't understand the symbolism of Christ's crucifixion. How can a fishing trip be worthy enough to stand for Christ's crucifixion?

I really don't understand much of what Waldmeir is saying. I haven't read any other books by Hemingway.

see the commentary here, done most well.

http://education.yahoo.com/homework_help/cliffsnotes/the_old_man_and_the_sea/27.html

Thanks, that helped a little. I'm beginning to see that this story seems to be a lot about how life is cyclic and how life leads to death and death leads to new life, something like that.

To understand why "The Old Man and the Sea" is considered a good book, it's important to explore the elements and themes that have resonated with readers over time. While personal opinions about books can differ, here are some key aspects that many people appreciate about this classic novel:

1. Deeply Human Struggle: "The Old Man and the Sea" explores the timeless theme of human struggle against formidable forces. The protagonist, Santiago, represents the indomitable human spirit, grappling with challenges and pursuing his goals against all odds.

2. Metaphorical Layers: Ernest Hemingway employs rich symbolism and metaphors throughout the book. The struggle between Santiago and the marlin can be seen as a metaphor for the broader human experience, including themes of determination, courage, resilience, and the pursuit of meaning.

3. Simple yet Powerful Language: Hemingway's writing style in this novella is characterized by its simplicity and directness. The concise prose and straightforward storytelling enhance the emotional impact of the narrative, allowing readers to empathize with Santiago's journey.

4. Exploration of Themes: The book delves into various themes, such as isolation, endurance, humility, and the interplay between man and nature. These thought-provoking themes can stimulate readers to reflect on their own lives and the universal struggles they encounter.

5. Sublime Descriptions of Nature: Hemingway's vivid descriptions of the sea and its creatures immerse readers in the beauty and vastness of the natural world. These passages can transport readers to a different setting and evoke a sense of wonder and appreciation for nature's power.

When reviewing a book, it's important to approach it with an open mind and consider both your personal impressions and the broader aspects that contribute to its reputation. By analyzing these elements, you may gain a deeper understanding of why "The Old Man and the Sea" has been celebrated by many readers and literary critics alike.