The songs Lift Every Voice and Sing and America the Beautiful both have religious refernces in the first stanza. Our current national anthem, The Star Spangled Banner does not. Traditonally only the first stanza is sung at baseball games and events.

I need to come up with points why we shouldnt replace our anthem with one of the two mentioned above. I need help in coming up with points and elaborating the one I already have about religious refernces and whats not good about it.

Thank you soo much for your help!!

If its not broken, why fix it?

If you want to emphasize the separation between church and state, then I would suggest an anthem without religious references.

I hope this helps. Thanks for asking.

Our national anthem has been exactly that since 1812. There really is no reason to change it...it works! Everyone knows it is our anthem. And besides it is fun to see how many people can really screw it up singing it a baseball games. <G>

It's also wonderful to hear it sung well. Until he retired, one of the coaches at the school where I taught in CA could really belt it out -- and well done, too! Hitting all the right notes.

There's no reason to change it.

see this thanks

When discussing whether to replace the national anthem with "Lift Every Voice and Sing" or "America the Beautiful," there are several points to consider. Here are some points you can use to support the decision of keeping the current anthem, "The Star-Spangled Banner":

1. Historical Significance: The "Star-Spangled Banner" has a strong historical connection to the United States. It was written during the War of 1812 by Francis Scott Key and represents the resilience and determination of the American people during a crucial time in the nation's history. It has been recognized as the national anthem since 1931, and changing it might diminish its historical and cultural value.

2. National Unity: The current national anthem serves as a unifying symbol for the entire country. Regardless of political beliefs, ethnic backgrounds, or religious affiliations, people from all walks of life can come together and sing the anthem to express their patriotism. Replacing the anthem may lead to division, as different groups might have varied opinions on which song should be selected, potentially undermining the unity it currently represents.

3. Familiarity and Tradition: The "Star-Spangled Banner" has become deeply ingrained in American culture and society. It is played at numerous events, such as sports games, ceremonies, and patriotic gatherings. Most Americans have grown up singing or hearing this anthem on various occasions, creating a sense of familiarity and tradition. Adopting a new anthem might require significant adjustment and could potentially face resistance from those who are attached to the current anthem.

4. Symbolism and Representation: While "Lift Every Voice and Sing" and "America the Beautiful" both have their merits, the current national anthem reflects the specific historical context of the United States. It emphasizes the endurance and resilience of the American people during trying times, as well as their commitment to liberty and freedom. The anthem's lyrics tell a story of the defense of Fort McHenry during the war, which resonates with the nation's history. Changing the anthem could result in a loss of such symbolic representation.

Regarding religious references, it is important to note that the absence of religious content in "The Star-Spangled Banner" allows it to be more inclusive for individuals from diverse religious backgrounds or those who do not identify with any particular faith. Removing the religious references from the other songs might actually make them more suitable for a wider range of people.

Remember to develop each point further by providing additional evidence, examples, or counterarguments. Ultimately, the decision about the national anthem should be based on a careful evaluation of its cultural significance, historical context, and the overall unity it inspires among the American people.