Managed care organizations emphasize drug treatment over counseling for children with behavior problems because it's cheaper
I said True
Is that right the other choice
it's proven more effective
-psychologists recommend it
I think you're right that True is the answer.
As for the effectiveness of either treatment -- it depends upon the patient. Obviously psychologists prefer counseling. But I think most doctors recommend a combination of medication and counseling.
thanks :)
To determine the correct answer, let's analyze both options:
1. Managed care organizations emphasize drug treatment over counseling for children with behavior problems because it's cheaper (True).
2. Managed care organizations emphasize drug treatment over counseling for children with behavior problems because it's proven more effective - psychologists recommend it (False).
To evaluate which statement is correct, we need to consider several factors:
1. Cost-effectiveness: Managed care organizations often prioritize cost-effectiveness when making treatment decisions. Drug treatment may be seen as a more cost-effective option compared to counseling due to various reasons, such as the cost of therapy sessions, the availability of drugs as a treatment option, or the potential for faster results with medications. Therefore, statement 1 might be correct.
2. Effectiveness: The effectiveness of drug treatment versus counseling for children with behavior problems is a matter of ongoing debate in the field of psychology. While medication can be effective for certain conditions, it may not address the underlying causes of the behavior problems. Counseling, on the other hand, aims to provide a comprehensive understanding and address the root causes of the behavior. Psychologists often recommend a combination of both drug treatment and counseling for optimal results. Therefore, statement 2 might not be entirely accurate.
Considering these factors, statement 1 ("Managed care organizations emphasize drug treatment over counseling for children with behavior problems because it’s cheaper") is more likely to be true, as managed care organizations prioritize cost-effectiveness. However, it's important to note that the approach should ideally involve a comprehensive treatment plan that includes both drug treatment and counseling, as recommended by psychologists.