Also a continued post from yesterday:
I am wondering then why it's asked this way, "BENEATHA is particularly bitter, BUT Ruth defends Walter. What does Ruth SAY?"
Why does the question mention Bennie at all? And it asks, "What does Ruth SAY?" She only says, "Yes, Lena," when agreeing to Lena about Walter becoming a man. Is this really DEFENSIVE?
When you don't want to "argue" about something... what do you say.... I say "yes?" Which interprets to go on, think it out.
I don't understand what you are saying. Could you please explain it to me again?
Ruth stood by Walter even when he is not being very smart. So when he finally comes to realize that "money" is not going to be the source of happiness, she agrees with Lena totally. Bennie, has to learn what is most important, just as Walter does. They are the "evolving " characters. Their "change" is what the play is about.
So, the answer to what does Ruth say would be "Yes, Lena"?
In the context of a scene or a play, it is common for questions to reference specific characters or events in order to provide context and require specific responses. In this case, the question mentions Beneatha and her bitterness to emphasize a contrast between her and Ruth, who is defending Walter. By mentioning Beneatha's bitterness, the question sets up a contrast between the two characters' perspectives.
Regarding Ruth's response, it is important to remember that a character's tone, body language, and context can contribute to the overall meaning of their words. While she may only say "Yes, Lena" when agreeing with Lena about Walter becoming a man, the way she says it and the context of the conversation may indicate a defensive stance. It is possible that Ruth's support for Walter is counter to Beneatha's bitterness and that her response is intended to defend Walter's actions or decisions in that moment.
To fully understand the meaning and tone of Ruth's response, it is essential to consider the surrounding dialogue, actions, and the author's intended characterization. Examining these elements will provide a more comprehensive understanding of the scene and Ruth's defensive statement.