Posted by John on Thursday, July 5, 2007 at 12:13am.
1. I wish he were a bird.
2. I wish he was a bird.
3. I wish I were a doctor.
I think #1 is correct. What about #2? Is it OK? And what about #3?
Numbers 1 and 3 are correct; 2 is incorrect.
Read about the use of subjunctive mood in English:
John, English has a subjunctive tense for three situations: a doubt, a wish, and a formal declaration such as making a motion in a meeting. I wish I were a bullfrog; if he were a prince, I wouldn't marry him; and I make a motion that the meeting "be" adjourned.
In specific answer to your question: I wish he were a bird would be correct--not I wish he was a bird.
1 and 3 are incorrect because the word were does not come with the third person singular.2 is correct
Norman, in the subjunctive ( a wish or something that is contrary to fact) "were" is correct. eg. "If I were a rich man". I am neither rich nor a man, so that is contrary to fact. Writeacher's corrections are "correct" <G>
I'm sorry, but your answer is exactly backward! 1 and 3 are correct; 2 is not.
Please read over the link above that explains about subjunctive mood.
Thank you for using the Jiskha Homework Help Forum. Unfortunately the subjunctive appears to be "dying" amont the general public! This is another reason to study a foreign language (Spanish and/or French) to truly understand that the subjunctive IS alive and well! The problem is that when so many people use English grammar incorrectly, it begins to be widespread, even appearing in newspaper print!
I agree with SraJMcGin. Incorrect English grammar is all over the place, including newspapers, television, blogs, you name it!
News and weather people can't even speak in complete sentences!
Thank you for your help.
I have to change the topic like this.
How can I change my typing error?
Answer this Question
- Poem - I also wrote this poem and this is deticated to my life. Does it sound ...
- Physics - The fastest bird is the spine-tailed swift, which reaches speeds of ...
- English - I can't send you my post. I hope this time I can. 1) Rewrite the ...
- English - (Choose the correct answer) i hope/wish i was a bird
- english-what would you wish for - This was the question of the day What would be...
- Advanced Biology - If a bird has a hooked bill and sharp talons, it might be a(...
- Math - If a 5-pound sack of bird seed is divided equally for 3 different bird ...
- PHI445 - Thomas Hobbes believes that most people in the state of nature would ...
- 12 Grade Physics - A bird accelerates from 15 m/s,north to 25 m/s,south in 8 ...
- math check again please - I have a slope of -3/4 and the y-intercept at 8 the ...